Skip to content
Movemental Partner

Sermons & talks

Address

Alan Hirsch | Everyone Everywhere at KCBC London | Part 1

Alan Hirsch · KCBC London

Watch in the video library

Transcript

Transcript of the recording.

Through Alan, in this time together. In Jesus' name. Amen. Thanks,

man. Thank you. Thank you very much. Awesome to be back with you. And, you know, whenever people introduce me like that, I think, who the heck is he talking about? I think, who's that dude? It's always a joy to be among people like yourself. I feel very much at home. I was, you'll turn the accent, is I was born and raised in apartheid South Africa, escaped, you know, when I was 22 and went to Australia. But, interesting thing about that is that, you know, on the English speaking side, at least the white people, it was very British. You know? So whenever I'm in England, I totally get it because I had more than British kind of upbringing. I kinda... I'm I'm inside it. I understand it very well, and I've always felt at home here in England and and in Great Britain. So thanks for having us. Just a few things more about me, k, because it'll make any sense of what we say today. Yes. I have no unpublished thought, and I do tend to be a little geeky. There's a good reason for that, actually, partly to... I invent words partly to get us beyond a veil of familiarity. You know? Epictetus, the philosopher, said it's impossible to teach a man. This works for you, sisters. It's impossible to teach a man what he thinks he already knows. And, you know, I've worked a lot in America. When you use the word church, oh, got that one worked out. Don't need to talk about that. We'll leave that. But in actual fact, sometimes familiarity is hugely problematic, And it takes a real effort to see what's right in front of our eyes and our faces. It's a paradigm issue, and I do talk about paradigms a lot. I'm gonna even maybe address that with you maybe today. I'm trying to follow the spirit and say what exactly I'm gonna follow. I'm just gonna go with it. Right? But another thing I should say, and this is a fair warning, I come from, I'm the lord of long answer. So I've asked people to discipline me if I go down to, you know, too detailed answers. But I do invite you to, to interrupt if you want. If you want clarity on a word or something I might use, feel free to shout it out. Just keep it on topic. Lest we go down, to many other kind of rabbit holes. So you can even heckle if you want to. I'm alright with that. Okay. Okay. So what I wanna do today, is just to maybe, start us off to maybe give us a common ground to stand on is to maybe give you a model of what I actually propose in The Forgotten Ways. Can I get a sense maybe in the room who might have actually read that book just to get a feel for it? Oh, there's quite a lot, and shame on the rest of you. I say this, you know, that is the center... My centerpiece work. And why? Because it actually... I felt, given the task of being a custodian of those ideas into the church. Now you'll know, for those who've read it, that I do believe this actually belongs to the church already. It's not my thinking particularly. I'm just ADD enough to see a pretty pattern and put a name onto it. But I actually... For me, it started with a journey, and I'm gonna give it to you very quick run, and then I'm gonna try and touch base on some of the, the topics that I see you guys are dealing with here, which are very good, by the way, and are all issues related to, I believe, the concept of the church's movement as a whole. So what I want to present to you today is a bit of a... We must say the technical term may may be a phenomenology of movement, a study of the phenomenon of movement, what factors have got to come together to precipitate movement that is a highly scalable, high impact form of ecclesia of church. Right? And and then what... You know, we can then just play around, and then I'll able to engage with you a little later. And I'm here for the rest of the time together too. Now I use this. This is a little itty bitty baby one. Hopefully, it'll work for us. My journey to this, started with me... Actually, it was here in Windsor. I... No. Sorry. The the journey started before I was at a conference, asked... The the speaker asked this question, and I knew my life was to be determined by the answer. And I I had to go seek out the answer of this. I don't even remember what else was said at the conference, went on to some other topic. But I... It's just one of those moments, you know, you feel called to something. And the question was, how does the early church grow from as little as 25,000, in year, year 100 AD and as little as 25,000. It could be more, and I suspect it wasn't, but it's a Rodney Stark's figure upwards to 20, million year, 300 AD. I've got those things on the other side. So the question for me, how did they do that? And like I said, that one of those moments, you know, oh my gosh. Yeah. How did they do that? To factor in the answer, they didn't have, buildings as we know it. There were some buildings that go back into the second, third, fourth centuries, but there were usually houses that were gutted and made into meeting halls. And then when persecution came along again, you know, taken out, they were persecuted, sometimes very severely, sometimes tolerated, never got charity status or tax exemption, all the stuff that you think we need to get the job done. They didn't have the bible, at least the New Testament at that time. There were fragments floating around the empire. It's more stories, really. The Jesus story was rich in the capacity to tell stories that define us. Didn't have seeker sensitive services, youth groups, worship bands. Oh, they might have had something like that, but I have no idea. But they they grew like that. So that was for me a question. How did they do that? And that set me on that journey. And then... So I got really caught up with this idea. So I'm gonna use this, like that exponential model, like the scalable model. I'm gonna put that there as a paradigm issue. So, like, the way of thinking about the church as a movement, a scalable kind of high impact thing is gonna be what... I'm gonna compare it a little bit with the prevailing paradigm that comes in the form of the legacy version of church, which kinda... No offense. We look something like this. Because whenever we think about church, we think this is... Well, this is... And and and, friends, I will say this to you that we are dealing with it. I'm I'm 65 now, and I've been doing this work a long time and trying to invite movement. The legacy thinking about the church, particularly out of the European context, is because where we got this from, the year 300, changed the game, how we understood ourselves as church, has... Is so incredibly deep, deeper than I ever thought it would be. And so what we've had to do in the last few years is try to develop processes, and I can actually deal with some of this, but processes that get us to the core of how you actually get to paradigm shift. Because the issue is the issue of paradigm. How we... And the paradigm is those irritatingly conceptual things, but it's it's kind of... You you know that picture of the old woman, young woman. Right? So you look at it and you think it's a young woman looking at me. She's a feather in a cap. And you blink, blink, blink, and then it's, oh, it's an older woman, and she's, like, in profile. And then you blink. You can't... By selecting the one, you deselect the other one. And so much of the way we had... We've been forced to think, actually, in the European setting, you were not allowed... You know this as Baptist as, you know, as as going against the kind of the grain in your early heritage to ask questions of the legacy church suffered for it. And the Baptists as well, you know, they were... That you... And your heritage, I do believe, is from more than Baptist stream, if I'm not mistaken. When you are... You weren't allowed to ask questions, so it was a very deeply ingrained thing. And then the presumption of how we think about church is very deep there. And that's what we've said, the legacy thinking, muscle memory, if you will, is incredibly deep. Default mode... And it it sets the default to how we understand ourselves as church. And, but I I would say that, again, the the kind of legacy model is is God has used it. It's not... It's a form of church, but it's not the only form. But for us, it's become the only one. And so most of our behaviors are very much formed in those ways. So, anyway, so often went, in history to try and find other times when you saw this begin to happen. And, I I almost, tackled the kind of the West Lee kind of early Methodism thing. Phenomenal movement changed. The world is changing it still. But, but I suck as a historian. And, you know, there were people that would take the history apart, but I'm just interested in the the phenomenon behind it. And I thought, no. I wanted something more contemporary anyway. So I ended up looking into the Chinese underground church phenomenon as much as I could. And and and this is interesting because they have the legacy model. Well, you know, the Christianity came into China or into the East through the work of the apostle Thomas going out east, started a number of, you know, churches in those settings, ended up with forms of orthodoxy, but also, nest... Historians. There were other kind of, you know, movements over there as well. And they were in China all these two thousand years. They've been around a long time. But the prevailing form of church in China at the time of Mao coming to power was, was really the European model. Because, of course, when Europe colonized the East, particularly China, we all brought our churches with us. So actually, the biggest church, in China at the time in Mao Zedong was the was the Roman Catholic church. But there were Anglicans there, the CMS, there were Baptists there, you know. There were Salvation Army. We were all there. I mean, all the stuff was there. And and under the conditions of, when Maldenstrom comes to power, he he literally deinstitutionalizes the church, literally overnight. Well, it was over a year. I don't know. Over some time. But it was like, everything's taken out. So building's confiscated. You and me, my friends, are... We're either kind of our throats or slit in public. This is what happens to you if you wanna follow Jesus, or we're sent to work in labor camps for the rest of our lives. You know the stories of that. You know, foreign missionaries cast out, seminaries closed down, building confiscated bible banned. And now you just got a group of uneducated peasants. And under these conditions, friends, and something happened in China to recover latent capacities, and I've got to name latent potentials, that under these conditions, the Chinese church recovers something and it goes to scale. And the best estimates now from 2,000,000 at the time of 1950, think about 1950, our best estimates now about a 120,000,000, and that's slightly dated now. Don't know, but it's around a 120,000,000 in seventy years. Now the base figure matters. Okay? So it's... The math is very similar, actually. But the phenomenon... What is most interesting to me is that the phenomenon of the two are, I mean, precisely the same. What I'm gonna share with you works in both places. In fact, it works for every movement that I've seen do this pattern. There are some cultural variations, but they're insignificant. In other words, something works over here over here, but they... They're not common. They're not essential to the idea of movement. And this is very hopeful for us, friends, because... And I I think this was the biggest insight for me is that, the church has latent capacities that lie dormant. Forgotten Ways, this is the name, lie dormant in us that under certain conditions can be reawoken. It could be in the case of a China adapt or die. By the way, if you think... Make the comparison between China and Russia under the same kind of conditions, similar time, the Stalinist revolution or, you know, Leninist would before, but the communist thing banned Christianity, went underground, but they just got pious and baptist and prayed. They didn't do anything else. In fact, they they declined. China, something else happens. Because there's not just one or two factors. There's there's a number of factors that are gonna come together, and I'll explain the system afterwards to you. And this we can use as a kind of a way of taking a mirror and look at ourselves, as we look into things. Before I I get into this, I I say this as a leader myself and having been... To be responsible, but there's a number of things here that I think are very, very helpful to us, and and and hard for us to to to take into. I asked the question of myself and you, what is it that the leaders in China were doing prior to Mao Tse Tung's revolution that was suppressing the potentials in god's people, that they had to be removed in order for god's people to get it. Now that's an interesting question because it asked the thing about us as being the kind of the the guardians of the paradigm, if you will, how we understand churches, really leaders do that. Here's the problem with this is that we are the beneficiaries of the prevailing system. Even if we have questions of it, we benefit from it. Hard to get someone to understand something when their salary depends on them not understanding it. Right? When... Or our identity or our sense of, you know, purpose is bound up with a certain model. Very hard to call it. And so we have to kinda give a little bit of distance there to say, okay, Lord, you know, what... To what degree do I play a role in the prevailing system even though I have critical critical thoughts about it? To actually... And also to realize that we... Finally, we are... We're employed by Jesus, and there are different way. You know, there are ways we can get to this beyond that. But just... It's worth asking the question. So to... My understanding is that leaders can be either bottlenecks or bottle openers, if you will. We can open up the things or we can close them down. And often because we're not even self aware enough to know what our own motivations are in these issues. So it's just worth putting that out there. Because I believe, friends, that the same capacity that is in the Chinese church that was recovered is in this room right now. And that there's a movement in each one of us that if, you know, that... Simon's the last believer in China. He isn't even a young one. He's not even that old as a believer. It can take him alone and create entire movement out of him. That was my conclusion. The way that, the underground church called, back to Jerusalem movement says it, every believer is a church planter. Every church is a church planting church. And so there's this idea that there's the capacity in each one of us. There's a movement. I'll give you another metaphor. In every seed, there's a potential for a tree. Would you agree with that? Yeah. And every tree is a potential for a forest, but it's all contained in the smallest part. Now this is gonna address an issue that's on your little list there. It's that the the the hole is contained in the smallest part. If you want the kinda geeky term for that, and it's a fantastic... The interesting view of organizations called holographic organization. And, there's a whole lot of stuff we can even... If you wanted to go down there. For some of you, it's not everyone's cup of tea, but in how you actually organize and making sure you don't... You you... Each person... You don't wanna overspecialize that people then have to rely on external sources. Everyone should be able to do the whole. Simplify in order to multiply would be an issue we'll go... We can touch about based on. Don't make it too professional that you need... Honestly, really, you understand and I believe in education. You'll find that I'm quite geeky on this. But not everyone should have to do that, in the same way. If it takes seven years of study to drive, you know, the church, well, you're not going very far very fast. No. I'm just saying... Or or... You know? And it doesn't make any sense of the bible anyway because they don't have that. So what we're seeing in our our most primal form of church is not that. So are there educated people here? Probably Paul was quite educated. But making that a precondition for what I got when I was baptized, which is my commissioning into god's agent... Agency of god's church, is is a silly move. And, again, it creates a kind of dependency on the system that can't scale. If your view of church... I say this more in America, but if your view of church requires that you have, you know, 200 people at least in the church plant before you can call in the church and a million dollar budget in the building, well, again, it's good. That's a church, but it's not gonna scale very much. So they're asking the question of scalability becomes very important at that point. And we have to, as leaders, take responsibility for the design of these things. Now I would say this too, and I haven't got to the points here, but but I'll just say that as leaders, we are responsible for designing a system to different outcomes. I call this front loading. You have to front load the design in the core, in the DNA piece so that the tree in the forest actually develop consistently with what you've designed. So... And that's a that's a... It's a joyous thing. You get to kind of maybe under the lord's... You know, the lord and the spirit's kind of guidance. You can actually redesign the church towards these outcomes. But then you often have to take out things that you're currently doing that are blocking those capacities, and then we can do another assessment on that a little later if we get to that. So where was I? Okay. Because that each part can reproduce a whole. The way it plays out in China, for instance, if... Let's say, this is underground church in China. You can grow to about 20, 25 people, maybe. You know? When you're underground, you're illegal. So 25, you're starting to look a little dicey. You're not just at family meeting together. So that's probably a point where you can't grow any further. So you've got 25 people. They evangelize like crazy. They're sharing the gospel because it's darn good news. And so what actually happens when someone else comes to the lord? Oh, no. No. No. You you can't. You can't join us. Not here anyway. So stay where you are, and we'll send two of our most mature disciples to be with you over there. So you're gonna start a church in your house, wherever that might be. It doesn't have to be a house, but it can be some other setting. In the meantime, this one is only two away from getting to the same point. So they said, no. No. You can't say it's gonna be like a rabbit. Right? Super fertile. In the meantime, this one might get to the place where it's 20 and it starts to reproduce. And all I'd say is, like, you can see the pattern emerge over here where, in a sense, each part is a seed for the whole. There's a movement in each one of us. Under certain conditions, this can be done. But the assumption is that we all carry the code. And and this goes to the issue of microchurch, by the way, and we'll come back at that a little bit. Because in a sense, this is what Microchurch offers you, a a very low expense, but you gotta organize differently. That's alright. Just find a way to organize. And that's where APES is gonna play because it gives you all the capacities to organize friends locally as well as locally. But, again, we'll come to that. We'll... I haven't got to the typology yet. But, all I'm saying here is that each part is a seed of the whole, and this is how it works. And you see the the movement form over here. And, again, this helps us to think about ourselves differently. It changes everything. So if in in this underground church movement, you became a believer, They say, what? And, you're filled with the spirit. They're very charismatic, very renewed. And, you know, you'd be, you know, born again, all that. It's fantastic. It's like, day you will plant a church. You say, will I? Yes. You will. It shall be your honor. Okay. Right? It's just assumed. And and what they mean by church and what we mean by church is a different thing. And that's the thing. Right? It's just assumed that it's... You've got... It's in you. And, again, this is something of what you're seeing in the New Testament, friends. It shouldn't be strange to us. The very fact that we find it strange means that we don't understand what's going on in the New Testament. Paul can go into Thessalonica. Now it depends on your date of two weeks to a month. He's not there very long. He gets kicked booted out, if you remember. And then he writes a let... Two letters back to them. He says... Calls them an ecclesia of God in Christ Jesus, the church. He says... And he says to one of them, I have no need to teach you anything. Woah. He can plant a church in one month and call it an ecclesia, give them the legitimacy in that. And that's another thing. It's like, you know, to understand ecclesia is something giving it back to the people of god. Yes. You want. No. He writes letters, so they have to learn. They're gonna be corrected in some ways. But it's there. All the potential is there in in in in the smallest part, and you can build on that. Again, there should be deeply instinctive form, of ecclesia. Okay. Let... I'm I'm scattering around. I'm... I was given permission to do that. And I wanna try and address some of the issues I see there. So inadvertently, you'll see some things being addressed there. My attempt of answering answering the question, how did they do it? Was simply this, that, to ask the question, I did it daily, daily, daily. I came up with six elements that come into play, that all six are needed for a movement to take place. Each one of them is magnificent, really good, gonna be very healthy leverage points in your local church community. But all six happen. Here's my assumption, and it... I think it's... You know, I work with this all the time. When we see this happen, when the six come together, you will have movement. It will go there under the power of the spirit, assuming all that, but this is how it goes. Jesus is lord. A kind of clarity at the very core of who we are, of who is the central character of the play. And it's it's the Jesus piece in in the equation. Now we we sang about the lordship of Jesus and bowing our knee. The thing is it's easy for us to do that confessionally. Of course, he's lord. But that's another thing, you know, in evangelical circles, and I say this lovingly and carefully, is that very often, we are actually not centered on Jesus. We call ourselves gospel centered people. In other words... And and by the way, that's a part of what Jesus is. Part of... I'll say it... Let me say it technically. We've collapsed our Christology into soteriology. Jesus is my savior, but he's not my lord. We don't have a lot to say about the kingdom side of the equation or teaching people to... In the obedience side of the equation. So you can you can actually just agree with the gospel in a Sunday service and you're in. That doesn't make sense in discipleship, friends. And I do wonder about that now. I actually really do. And, and I think, you know, when we call ourselves gospel centered people, it's... It it seems so right, but it's wrong. I can't see that anywhere in scripture that you're meant to be gospel centered, evangelical. Right? Someone correct me, please. I'm more than happy to be corrected, but I don't think it's there. Are we meant to be Jesus centered? Oh, yeah. Who's gonna argue with that one? Because the... And and because the the person you put in the middle makes all the difference, friends. It sets the... And I'd say this character and content is there. Now the gospel's included in that because he's your savior. But it's not just one... And by the way, when people are like, you know, what the heck? You know, go on the gospel centered, go collision kind of things. And then... But then what they're saying is the gospel is a very... It's a narrow understanding of the gospel. It's usually around atonement theory. Is it kinda legal? Substitutionally atonement, which I agree in. I don't disagree. I'll take atonement anyway God wants to give it. Anyway... But is that the only thing that matters? I mean, there's all the other kinds of understanding of what goes on in the cross and all that. Why not include them all in? And then, of course, all the other stuff of Jesus' teachings that are central because he's our lord. So you can't skip over that stuff. And so it sounds right, but it's fundamentally wrong. And I think this is a very deep brokenness in our theology. And you know what? Again, pick on Americans here. Any Americans? I've worked in America fourteen years, still do. It's foobar is a word they might use. You can figure that out. It's a mess at the moment, and it's demonstrating that gospel centeredness does not produce Christ likeness. Well, of course, it's not trying to. It's trying to produce belief. You only have to believe certain ideas, friends. You don't have to follow. There's no obligation to discipleship because it's predicated on nondiscipleship. You only have to believe. But how does it make sense of Jesus? Where you... He calls us to a certain pathway of die. You know? And this is... I I believe, friends, and I say this with great grief in my heart. I'm Jewish. Right? I I remember the Holocaust. My families were wiped out and that stuff. The most Christian nation in Europe produced the holocaust. Yeah? And and Bonifour called it... Essentially, it was based on nondiscipleship, and we'll come to the issue of discipleship now. And and he says somewhere... He said, like, a church without discipleship is a church without Christ, and a church without Christ is inevitably a church without discipleship. So I've called it what it is, Christless Christianity. It's Christianity as a doctrine, but it's not based on Jesus. And I say this again, and I say, this grieves me deeply, and I work with it, but I'm I'm... I cannot... I have to call it now. So say, if a group of people claiming to be a church doesn't look, act, sound, and think like Jesus, is it a church? Is it a church if it doesn't look like Jesus? And I have to say no. But look at our marks of the church, friends. That's our stat... The standard way how we define churches. It's all about sacraments. Right? Depends if you, you know, charismatic... If you're Catholic, it's got seven. If you're kind of, you know, high church, you got a few more. Baptist, two. But, really, I know a lot of churches that preach, and they do, you know, baptism and Lord's Supper, but they are, yeah, not so Jesus y. If you can define the church without Jesus, you can probably run the church without Jesus too. And I think that's the problem. Our definitions are wrong. We have to correct this. We have to come back to Jesus and bow the knee and become... And this goes to the issue of discipleship. And, again, I I don't wanna be preaching, but this to me is the the most central thing because no matter what you do on the other side, if you get this wrong, everything goes wrong. And I'll you why that's the case because there's a sociology at work here when you put them all together. So let me go the next way that I won't get... Yeah. Go. Well, that's again... That's the, yeah, that's the atonement theory idea. And it... It's true. It's just not the whole thing. And I would say it's coming... You're you're much more coming into... We're introducing people into the relationship that defines their life, which is a commitment to this person called Jesus, and it's a lordship equation. He also happens to be wonderfully our savior. So not just... It's reductionism is our problem. By the way, I'll give you... I'm I'm happy for all of you get... I've I've given Simon all of these books already. Please just share them around. My attempt to grapple with this very issue is in the book called Reformation, which is how we've made things so small, god in a box. What? Friends, if it's god in a box, it's not god that you got. It's... The bible calls it an idol. If... And and, you know, this is like this attempt to kinda put doctrinal boxes onto the thing. You can't do that. Doesn't work. And it it it it fundamentally... It makes a big error. And, again, I think it's a big mistake. So reductionism, making things small, smaller gospel, have a bigger gospel dealing with all aspects of the human condition, not just our guilt. We are guilty. God will deal with that. But it's not the only thing I deal with. I've got shame and powerlessness and alienation and loneliness. And I lived in, New York for a while working with Tim Callebay, Gospel Center. But, anyway, I was there, and I... My wife had to leave me for for a while. Her family was in bitter crisis, so she... Back in Australia. She went back, and I'd never been lonely before. But I I mean, I felt, like, painfully lonely in... Because everyone's... If you know, we're in New York, I mean, there's singles, like, off the wazoo. And I felt I was channeling the city. And I said, what's the gospel for a lonely person? It's community or relationships. Right? That's good news. Why not start there? Why start with the kind of thing that deals with guilt which they don't feel? Because they're not like Luther having before holy god, right, with his panic attacks. He's an Augustinian monk in the middle... Medieval world. Right? They thought, you know, god... They had a certain different understanding of god. Well, much of our narrative was formed in that. Is that the only way to communicate the gospel? Really? And we got us down to this thing. Most people today don't feel guilt in the way that Luther did. At least first, they are guilty, but God will deal with them. Start with... So one of the things we say, you know, in helping people be missionaries, there's two fundamental questions you ask. What is good news for this people group? What's gonna sound like a year, baby? Yeah. What's gonna resonate with them? Now to do that, you have to listen. And the guy invented the stethoscope said, listen. Listen. Listen to your patients. They're telling you the answer. And then you bring... Because the the bible gives us so many things about, like, good news and not just our guilt, but so many other things are dealt with. And we bring those to bear in the equation. But we've been narrowed down to reductionist gospel. And we got a whole lot of people who don't relate to it, and that's the problem. But it's... The answer's there. It's just bigger than we thought it was. Think bigger, not smaller, friends. And I think that's a Protestant problem because we're always arguing with things. It's true. It's built into our very logic. And, again, I'm going off the side. Sorry. I showed you the little long answer thing, but it's important. What is good news for this people group? What is church for this people group? Not presuming it's the same. That what you do here... And this is the whole incarnational narrative that you have to... That in different settings, the church might look very different. It's different in in in Corinth as it is in Jerusalem. There are some common features, and I think we'll come to that when I look at your... What I call a minimal ecclesiology for a micro church kind of idea. I'll do that a little later, I think. Let me get on with things. Is that good? We can come back a bit. I'm around. We can talk. Jesus is lord. Discipleship, disciple, maybe. Here what we say is absolute clarity of what it means to be a disciple. And I would argue here is where the Jesus factor comes in. Because discipleship is how Jesus gets into the church or into you, into the church, into the world. It's... Discipleship is how you take Jesus seriously. You follow. You you attenuate your life to that life. You tune yourself to that. So imitation of Christ, becoming more and more and more and more like Jesus. I'm more like Jesus this year than I was last year, and I will be more like Jesus next year than I am now. And you will hold me accountable to that, and I'll hold you to that. That's what community is about. So discipleship is critically important. Paul doesn't use the word disciple anyway, but he has... It's so cooked into the theology. Union with Christ. He lives in me. I live in him. Wow. It's like, woah. That's another level. The inner teacher. I live with the kind... I can operate in the mind of Christ. The mind that created the universe. That is to those who are mature, who disciples actually can operate with the mind that created the universe. Woah. That's amazing. Well, that's another thing. I love this one. We who... Like, it says in second Corinthians three, we're beholding him, gazing, contemplation is the word, theoria, gazed at him, are being transformed into his likeness from one degree of glory to another. This is from the lord who is the spirit. Spirit's job is to make me more like Jesus. That's the fundamental role of the spirit, to interpret Christ to me. And... But it's it's deeply inter... And the other one, of course, again, quite a scary one, actually. I think our eternal destiny is to be made into the image of Jesus Christ, Romans eight twenty eight twenty nine. Eternal destiny, is to be like Christ. If you don't like Jesus now, don't like hanging around with that radical, you're gonna hate heaven. And I would argue, actually... My actually thinking is that you're not gonna be in heaven because it says our eternal destiny is to be conformed to Jesus. Right? That's discipleship, friends. You can't be conformed without discipleship. It doesn't happen. It's not just believing certain ideas. And it's a process. As I say it like this way, god will have us Christ like or he will not have us at all. That's what I think it's saying. Correct me if I'm wrong. And we have to take that seriously. So we have to factor discipleship into the equation. That's... And how you do that is disciple making. Now I've got some... You know, I wanna get to the other ones and maybe come back at this. But there are ways in which you can begin to... Disciple making is making sure you bake it into the system. It's not an optional expert. It's not just a heads of doctrine, you know, twelve week course. Optional. But it's actually deeply structured. The whole church is structured around it. And if people don't wanna do it, you say, please, there's other churches if you wanna just listen to sermons. Please go there. But we wanna become all our Jesus here. We wanna be a Jesus y people. And it's not gonna be that bad. We'll have a lot of fun, and we'll, you know, have a lot of fun in the time. Jesus is a party animal, by the way. I love that about him. Turns up the wine at the wedding. They were ready with two sheets to the wind, by the way. That's a... And, I'm I'm a party. I like the party. It's... He's holy party animal, so it's really good. Anyway, I was just saying, there's so much that we can learn, and and we have to be disciplined in designing a system that does that. And I said that most of the ways we do church, at least not here, but, you know, the other places I work, are designed around nondiscipleship. It literally is predicated not on discipleship. You only have to believe. Now I believe you have to believe, but there also be a pathway to become mature Christ like people, little Jesuses. I remember c s Lewis saying something like this that that if if if... The the fundamental task of the church to make little Christs. And all the other stuff that we're doing, if we're not doing that, is meaningless. Like, even this is the bible. All the things we do don't matter at all. If you're not doing that, you're not doing it. And I think it's absolutely right. It says on a number of occasions, actually, very profound. Because that's that one. Let's go to missional incarnational impulse. I put this as sorry about my language. I told you, like, I warned you in the front. But it's actually... It shouldn't be something we don't understand. Missional is the word missio sent, sending, missile. So sent incarnation is the way we are sent. And and here, the beautiful thing is this is modeled on our deepest theology of god, that sentness is who god is. It's not, you know, it's... He he sends the sons. The the son is is eternally sent, you go back to the procession, eternally sent. And as a father sent me, so I send you. We are sent. The spirit is sent into. Sentness is who God is. It's not so much the church as a mission, but the mission as a church. Sentness is to ecclesiology. Now what that does is means that you do you do church and you have to work out. So you do mission and the church comes out the back, and don't be too visual about that. But mission proceeds and and you... So in different settings, the context is gonna determine how we determine the church. But why this is important? Because if we if we don't do that form, you actually front load your understanding of the church. Remember? It's put onto other people rather than having a church that actually fits their culture, which is the incarnation mode. So how do movements go? Sending, out, going out, going deep into culture, contextualizing both gospel and the church. Not just one. Good at gospel contextualization, but you have to put the church on the table, your ecclesiology. Out deep. Out deep. Out. Begin to see that swoosh begin to take place. And it's based on excellent theology, deep biblical theology of the incarnation and on the mission of god. It's pretty, pretty big. Apeist culture. And this is a is a killer killer rep. Like, a killer rep, they say in America. It it resolves just about everything. Because it's the apostle, if you don't know what I'm talking about, there's apostle, prophet, evangelist, shepherd, teacher, the biblical typology in Ephesians four. And Jesus, he ascends to heaven, commissioning act in the resurrection. And the other ascension is the great commission. You know? So that's the big ascension thing. And then, of course, the Pentecost is associated with ascension too. Unless I go to the father, the spirit can't come. So, oh, this is a big idea. Right? It's not like... It's like the commissioning of the ecclesia in its most fundamental form. As he ascends, he gives gifts. Right? And the gifts he gives is apostle, prophet, evangelist, shepherd, teacher, which are his own identities and purposes bequeathed upon the body of Christ. The body of Christ is the recipient, the receptacle of Christ's ministry. The fivefold are his ministry, friends. And I know the Christology pretty well. It's been my life studying it. When you look at Jesus and look at it in fivefold, I believe it contains all of what he does. It's an excellent ecclesiastology. Better than the ministriplex, which is alright, but that's that's somewhat alien description. This is right there. And Jesus, as he he he gives his own functions and identities to the ministry or to the body of Christ so that... And this is the... In the in the text that we might attain to the fullness of Christ. The fullness of Christ is associated with apeist, my friends. If you mess around with that, you mess around without the capacity to be the body of Christ as Jesus intended us to, which is, by the way, Ephesians four, 12 onwards is about the church at, you know, let's say in American terms, it's a kick ass church. It's doing the work. It... Every part connected to the whole that is Christ, and, you know, it's it's growing and, you know, doing its thing. It's associated with a pest. Not just one, not just two, but at least five if you want 20, fine, but not less than fivefold. And, I can go on... I've written four books on that, by the way. So I can obsess a little bit. I won't go there. But I'm saying this is very important. My latest book on this is five, fivefold, is on... Called five q, and we have people here too that we... We've done a good lot of work in trying to create resources and training and coaching in that. And so, Simon, we... I don't know where you are right over there. Does... He represents us in in, in our... In this part of the world, and, you know, I'm sure he's happy to help you. But we got some things that can really help in that regard. So APEST, all the functions of ministry are contained there. You think about it. Apostolic sentness, it's a missionary function, experimentation, pioneering work, new forms on the edges. It's quite innovative because you have to be. And it goes into different parts of culture. It's a pushing outwards., one who is sent. Same word. It's essentially a missionary function. It's not your mojo. Not that you're dominating anyone. That's a very bad interpretation. Paul calls him the false apostle. The apostle is really essentially a sent function. It's important and and designs the church for scalability, which is that that issue there. Prophet is aligning with god's purposes, essentially, calling us to faithfulness and loyalty. The vertical is the worship mission... Sorry, worship, prayer, mystical relationship. Very important. The other one is the horizontal or the, you know, the vertical and horizontal. Horizontal one is about justice. You shall be holy because the Lord your God is holy. Living out what the what the Methodist call social holiness. You know, a community that kinda lives it out and makes it think. So that's very important. Basically, it's an aligning function, like the guardians of the covenant. Evangelist is the recruiters, of course, the singer of the song, the messenger inviting people into the story of Jesus as it unfolds. You need that for church growth. Shepherds create community and defend it. They're not the only ministry friends. Why would you call everyone shepherds? The bible doesn't. And by the way, it's the only only time the noun is used in the bible or the ministry of believers, I'm not kidding you, is here, once. How did it become the catchall phrase for every form of ministry? Now there are some other adjectives in there, you know. I'm not I'm I'm not dissing it. I'm just saying it doesn't carry the weight you put on it. Not everyone's a pastor. How did we get there? What happened to the other ones? Teacher 44 times in the bible, you know, most of it to be false teachers, actually, to be honest. And we know that teachers can mess with your brain. Right? You know this from European history. But... You know? And there's a qualification. Not many of you should be teachers. And there's a good reason for that. All I'm saying, friends, is that fivefold is that if you're gonna be a movement of the people of god, and this is bad because I'm wrong angle, to be on this side of the equation, you need all five here. You need both... I call it generative ministry to generate new forms, apostle, prophet, evangelist for different reasons, generate new form, and operative to maintain it, to keep integrity. And I I could go on. Let me go on. Yeah. Let me at least finish this, and we can pick this up later on. Organic systems has to do with, how movements organize themselves. We tend, I think this is all all kinds of things all, you know, built into the Roman thing, but we tend to centralize power and function and go hierarchical in power. That tends to be the way of the world. What movements do is to go exactly opposite to decentralize pound function and and and... So that the edges are productive, so that the edges are creative and that you actually often learn from the edges. You... It's reproducible, scalable, spread like a virus. There's all kinds of networking theory in here too. Just a different way of organizing ourselves. If you don't pay attention to that, the standard forms will just grab you every time. So it's the structure. And it's not sexy, but if you don't pay attention to structure, it will pay attention to you. And so you need to... Know, something we can do about that, and I think we need to do things about that finally. I'm sorry about the language again too, but I'm struggling with the kind of community that I was seeing in in movements. So I come up with this... Victor Turner comes up with this idea, communitas. So liminality in communitas is a word liminality communitas. Liminality is a conditions of risk, danger, ordeal, challenge, marginalization, disorientation, COVID, things like that. It's a bit... It's a disruptive kind of experience. It can sometimes just be a sports team, by way. Communitas is the kind of community that is formed in the context of danger, deal, challenge, risk, da da da. Right? So it's it's the bonding. And you think about your your your football team. And all of a sudden, in the room, it goes all up. You're right? And you... Because you've got all the things going on at the moment. Because there's a bonding even with the audience and and supporters have got a bonding with the team. That's community to us, for instance. It's a it's a very common everyday version of it. But liminality is the conditions that precipitated. We tend to be risk averse. Well, the thing is that, therefore, we miss out on that bonding that comes about like, in in missionary environments. All unnecessary. And I I wanna come back at that maybe later with... To talk about a minimal ecclesiology to think about microchurch, because I think it's very, very important how you organize and and make a lightweight version of church. If I got... I've got about five minutes, so let me do that. But all are necessary to create a movement. I don't think you're gonna be an underground church movement in... Like China here. Unlikely. But you can move towards that. You can move towards that. Each one of these are, like, levers of huge change in your organization. And I believe, again, we need to take responsibility for designing the church to the certain outcomes we want. Let me say it another way. You're perfectly designed to produce what you're currently producing. Perfectly. Absolutely perfectly. If you're in decline, it's probably... It's not because of external conditions, friends. It's because you are designed for decline, and you have to take responsibility to do something about that. If I... If... I'll give you example. If I wanted to produce v eight engines and I create a factory to produce v eight engines, but down at the edge of the... At the end of my production line, I'm getting light bulbs popping out the other side. Right? Thinking, what the heck? Well, how's that why's that happening? Right? It's because, actually, there's something going along in the production. If you wanna produce disciples but you're not getting that, I'm suggesting you is you're not designed to produce disciples. And you have to redesign it. And that's why I'm I'm I'm just saying I'm saying take responsibility for that. Don't leave it to the legacy thinking because the legacy thinking is the problem that we have to face at the moment. That muscle memory from from the Christendom past is still there holding us to a certain way of thinking and doing, and we have to think differently. It's a deliberate choice. Do it collectively. We'll send you a book called Metanoia, which is our tent... Organization I'm part of running. It's called Movement Leaders Collective. It's got... It's based on the concept of metanoia, which, of course, should be... We should understand what that is. It's so baked into the bible, into biblical spirituality, but we don't really know it. Metanoia is badly translated repentance, which comes away from the Latin word penitentia, which is what Justin, as he translates the Greek into the Hebrew... As in Greek into the Latin way back in the fourth century, he takes the word metanoia penitentia, which is... A part of it is what we feel penitence. We feel sorry for our sins before God. But, gee, you know this. Right? We wanna do that. You're ashamed of that? I am. I sin. I I do this every day. Lord, really. I'm so sorry. Appropriate. It's not... It's a reduction of what the real thing is about. Repentance is meta, noia. Meta, above, over, beyond. Noia, thinking, mouse, mind, to rationality. Thinking fundamentally differently to the way you're thinking now. And it's this reiterative cycle of learning, of ever greater thinking. And if you don't have this mind, you won't understand Jesus. This is what happens. The first... When Jesus comes along and says, the kingdom of God is at hand. The kairos moment is now. Saturated time. God is here. Repent and believe. Repent metanoia. Not just repent of your sins and believe, but repent metanoia and believe. And here's the thing, as I say as a Jewish fella, it grieves me that the very people who were formed for four thousand years to actually be the called people to bring messiah into the world because they had nonmetanoic minds, weren't able to see him. Because here's my friends. If you're not able to metanoia, you will never understand Jesus. You won't understand him. And it happens all the time because we're not open minded about this thing. We have closed little narrow grumpy kind of things going down. Open to god and be on a learning journey to do better, ever greater, never smaller, always bigger. And that's where... Again, we have tools. I'll send them to you. I'm sorry about all my words. And they gave me... My time is up, which you probably think, thank god. It's finishing now. But I'll be around, and we'll talk a bit later too as well. Thank you

very much. So just... I'm sure like me, your mind is just, isn't it? What? Like, a thousand notes and thoughts. So, what we want to do now is to deliberately create a space, a long space, an hour plus kind of space, to talk this through, to work this out. We are consciously today trying to lean to different learning styles, different preferences. You know, some of us would really benefit from an hour long lecture style. Others are gonna much more benefit from talking around the table, and I I have to hear myself speaking. It's not worth listening to me till the end of my thoughts, you know, because I'm I'm working it all out along the way, verbal processor. So we are intentionally doing that. So the space we're offering now, is, an hour or so long to go into kind of breakout discussion discussion groups. Groups. It's sort of a soft lunch at one. What I mean by that is not that it'll be easy to digest. I mean, if your conversation is rich and wonderful, then carry on till ten past one or quarter past one. Does that make sense? You know? But from lunch... From 01:00, lunch will kind of be ready. And the key thing to clock in your mind is we're back in here at 01:45. So that's the kind of key thing to clock back together at one 01:45. We're gonna create four, spaces in this room, looking at, four of the real big themes that particularly work out at the kind of local level or the practitioner level you're planting, you're you're leading a church. There's another group who would have received an email from from me. We're gonna go in a back room out the back, out the way. So that group is is out this room, so this room can really focus on those key, things. You should have a piece of paper on your table, which on one side lists, a bunch of, lists all the key... All the themes as we talked about earlier. On the other side, we'll have one like that in bigger in bigger letters. So the way we're gonna organize this is these front couple of tables here are gonna be particularly delving in and talking about that reproducing discipleship question. Does that make sense? So if if you'd like to really delve into that question of how do you reproduce, multiply disciples, create that movement of disciples, you're gonna be, in this kind of front, space. Move over here to the front. These couple of tables here, we'll be particularly thinking about those diverse APEST teams. So how do you build teams where perhaps the the pastoral and the organizational voice are still heard, but there's volume being turned up on some of the apostolic or evangelistic or prophetic voices? You know, how do you make sure you're hearing in stereo in your teams the full breadth of the gifts of leadership that God has given the church. So this space is gonna be more the kind of diverse teams thing over here. I think over towards this back end, these tables, do you have local movement? No. What have you got? Just remind me. You've got the fourth... So you've got microchurch. So if you wanna particularly think about microchurch stuff, Tom is your table microchurch as well. So you'd be kind of these these middle two here, kinda gather around these, particularly thinking about microchurch. And not just starting a microchurch but protects a movement or network of microchurches, or maybe you're... You've got a kind of conventional church, what it would look like to build an astro... Asteroid field of microchurches around that central expression, you know, thinking about that whole thing to do with micro churches. And then over here, you guys must have local movement. Is that... Jonathan, is that your your bit of paper? Local movement. Your local movement back there, Keith, as well. Local movement. So around here, you wanna think about how do I create... How do I shift from being a local church that gathers recipients to a band of evangelists that are sent out into the world? How do I create the systems and culture that actually what my church is about is really sending and releasing and empowering and creating movement as opposed to to gathering it? So does that make sense? So four kind of spaces. And what I've invited, Alan and Dot are gonna be in the room. And Alan will bob round depositing his wisdom. Also, don't think the mental image of that either. That was that was poor too, wasn't it? Not thought through. But Alan Alan will be moving around and kind of wanting to be drawn into your conversation. So you might want to invite him over if you hit a gnarly bit that you think I really want... You know, Alan, can you come join us for a bit? Or you'll find him appear at your table, your discussion at some point to do that. What I've invited doc to do is actually to to move around the room and bring prophetic prayer to every discussion. So I'm I'm deliberately using the word prophetic or prophecy. Now I I totally understand we'll have mixed response to to what what do you mean by that, Alex? Some of us were very comfortable with that idea of prophecy. Others will will feel very uncomfortable. Some will just be in a bit of ground and saying, what is he talking about? I have no idea. I think one of the things that's really helped me to understand is sometimes god gives people a particular ability to see what others can't see, particular insight to see what others can't see, and we should invite them to say what they are seeing. Does that make sense? And and and that sight, and I'm confident that doc will do it appropriately and well and bring it with prayer, that sight might be hindsight. She might have something that will really help you see something that's been that you need to undo or rebuild or reconstruct. Does that make sense? Give give you hindsight to really understand something that's causing an issue in the present, but the problem is in the past, and you need her hindsight to see it and go, okay. Or it could be something that's insight. Right now, she just brings something that's like light bulb moment. Of course, that's what's going in. Sometimes she might bring you something that's foresight. She's gonna see her horizon that you can't quite see. God's gonna help her to see something foresight that you can't quite... And she'll say, what about this? Have you seen weight? And you'll go, ah. Does that make sense? So I'm not expecting, by the way, flames above dots heads or or wind across the room. Like, sometimes, like, the bible says as a gift of administration. It's very normal. It's very common. The bible says as a gift of prophecy. It's very normal. It's very common. Doesn't need to come with bells and whistles and fireworks. It can... Comes with Dot who who is all bells and whistles and fireworks, obviously, but it just comes with Dot coming up and saying, as I've just been praying, I feel God has said this, and I'd like I'd like to wonder with you whether it's relevant for where you're at. It might help you hindsight, insight, or foresight. I hope everyone feels able to to welcome that. And, obviously, as a big group with a number of people hearing from DOT at the same time, there's lots of safety and confidence in that, isn't there, in terms of actually processing that. So I have welcomed Dot to to do that. If you feel at all uncomfortable, just signal to Dot, and she'll just say that's absolutely fine. Yeah. Does that does that make sense? What you could also do with Dot is say, dot dot dot, we're having a real issue here. Come pray. Pray for us. And Dot will come along as an outside voice.