Address
Alan Hirsch Kairos Conference 2015
Alan Hirsch
Transcript
Transcript of the recording.
[Alan Hirsch] Welcome you here, Alan. We're looking forward to hearing what you have to say. Welcome. Thank you. Thanks, Martin. It's true. We we do go back a long way. It's a it's a great joy to have known Martin over the years. I'm gonna need to move around a bit. Can I just loosen this up a little bit? Martin, would you mind just making sure that I don't tip things over? First, I I I always am so terribly honored to be here with you. I often wonder what am I doing here. I mean, like, I'm a Jewish kid from South Africa, old drug addict kinda party animal. And here I am talking to this, like, amazing group of people, kind of representing kind of European leadership. I I I often feel like I'm living someone else's life. And it's... But it's it's it's kind of very exciting, and and I I never take these these times. I always take them seriously. I I I feel the weight of it and I... The significance of the moment. And thank you for being here, and thank you for even putting up with just just whatever forty five minutes you have to put up with me. I I am honored with that. Normally, love a guy... A good give and take of the conversation, but the idea of this one, we'll process it later, I'll be around anyway, happy to talk as we go through the next few days together. I am... I do I do think we come together in a time of huge crisis for Christianity in the West. I mean, I'm saying something we all know. It's a pivotal time called the age of the unthinkable, where we're trying to appropriate or to begin to engage in the twenty first century largely on understandings of the church that derived from previous centuries, largely if you're Protestant from the sixteenth century, but derivatives from elsewhere. There's no doubt there's resources in our tradition, but the twenty first century is a very different phenomenon. It's a... Everything's connected. A little grease goes down, we all go down with it. Everything... It's a butterfly effect, right? And simply appropriating ideas from another era, another time willy nilly and applying them into our interconnected world is actually going to create more problems than we resolve. We have to be willing to think outside of the box if we're going to resolve our problems. Unfortunately sixteenth century ecclesiology is not quite going to make it anymore. It was a different time, a different place, right? You know that. Christendom and we're living in post Christendom. The theme of the conference here is of course kairos, and I do believe that's the kind of the word, it's that weighty prophetic time when when usually it comes along with a call to repentance actually. Kairos is a time when God's spirit moves upon us and the Kairos of God is at hand, repent and believe the gospel, as the first words in Jesus's mouth. Right? There's usually a move of God requires that we capitulate something of our prior understandings, and metanoia by the way is not simply change of your rational mind, it's change your mindset and your orientation. The Jewish word Shuvu, turning, means you turn your whole body. It's your orientation to life that needs to change. I believe we are in a time for a paradigm shift. Now I I probably would like to spend my time on that, but I'm not going to. I'm gonna try and address issues of our best... Most fundamental message and the medium that delivers it. The medium and the message, which is the message... The medium is the church, of course, the message being fundamentally the gospel. It's interesting as I as I say, we all love New Begin here, and I had one privilege at one time having dinner with him. He was just a remarkable man, very godly man. And one of the images he used here, and I speak in Europe as your friend deeply. I've seen many friends here, by the way. It's great. Newbighan also had another image when he came back from Europe. He talked about Christianity in this context of being like a rock in a river. And being in the river, you know, you take a nice little rock, it's been rounded off by the water of, you know, flowing over the river for so many years. It's nice round, smooth edged rock. And then when you break the rock open, it's dry on the inside. It was of course wet on the outside, and he would say that Christianity never really changed the heart, it never got to the epicenter, it was a veneer of it, and therefore you know, that we never really, maybe truly, really understood the gospel in its deepest understanding, they could let go of it very quickly. Anyways, this another image just to to say that one of the challenges he he did lay up in in front of us was to be willing to kind of renegotiate the social contract that the church has with society. We need adopt a missionary stance in relationship to our own context. We need to think like missionaries and act like missionaries now here, and we need to become... That's that's a fundamental shift, and hence the missional conversation. I want to address you, of course, as leaders leaders responsible for your generation, and and and also with understanding that as leaders in God's in the kingdom, but in God's economy, that decisions that we make now will matter. On the images that Max Weber, the sociologist, used about shifting... I came here on trains. This is kind of playing with me. You know, like a train is heading in a certain direction, but that Weber talked about shifting the tracks and changing the course of history. I believe we're in one of those pivotal times now that when decisions made now will shift the tracks, or we won't. But if we continue on the way we're doing it now, we end up... Well, the trajectory isn't good. I'm studying in in The Netherlands at the moment, a PhD, and I mean, the the the statistics there are are frightening, actually. Ten years ago, were 12,000 congregations, Protestant congregations in in The Netherlands. Now they're 5,000. I'm rounding it off. That's ten years. Where's that going, folks? Make decisions now because you won't have the opportunity much later. I don't believe you will. So we we need to to be very determined, and we need to feel something of the urgency of this situation. I want to just, you know, in introduction to feel that way. I wanna hang... I wanted... In the first half of my conversation my talk is to kind of introduce just some concepts that are very basic, but I wanna hang some ideas on them. And then from there on, wanna come up with some analysis and take us to the medium and the message. Okay? So the first one was a concept developed by an amazing man called Ralph Winter. He was a missiologist. He did most of his work in helping prepare people to go to missionary environments in in the non Western world. And he came up with this idea called cultural distance. Cultural distance, I'm not going to be anything like him, right, so don't compare, but he would say that each of these numbers represents a significant cultural barrier to the meaningful communication of the gospel. Okay? So if you stand... You you basically assume that you stand here or your organization or church is over here, in order to communicate meaningfully across cultural barriers you have to take a different strategy along the line. So if I say you were going overseas to a non Western context, what would be a significant cultural barrier to the meaningful communication of the Gospel? Language is the most obvious one, right? So agree with me now folks that when we say that you have to learn language, it's got a whole lot harder on you, right? That takes a long time to really get into the nuance and and even the mindset that each language brings along with it. Another one, I'll play this out quickly, another one might be worldview or religion. So if you're going to the East, you're entering into a completely different way, framework of thinking, plausibility structures are very different, all that stuff. Right? Another one would be a people's racial history or their history, their story, their defining narrative as a people. So if you're hanging out over here, if you're coming from a Western expression of ecclesia and you're hanging out over here, here you are in Saudi Arabia where we've hardly had any impact at all. We've been there as long as the Gospel's been around with almost zero impact as far as we can determine, because it's tough, because it's a much more sophisticated place, you can't simply assume that what you do over here is going work over here, okay? That's the first idea. The problem is folks is that for us, and this is very much a European experience, and by the way, I'm from Australia, so something very similar to the European marginalisation of the church. Of our thinking and our doing and our expression and our forms and our everything is formulated in a time when we were the M0 M1 connection with culture. Now M0 M1 you can simply say you're using evangelism, it's outreach, but your assumption is you're not having to communicate across a cultural barrier. The problem is over here or over here or over here, that's a different story. Outreach can work within an M0M1 framework, but it doesn't work so much over here, because you've got to take culture seriously, which is what I think Martin was saying, is it's all in the culture, right? So it's important, and I find this useful is because we've normally used this kind of thinking for our engagement in the non Western contexts, and it works for us there. But the problem is that we have to... In the Western world, it's all gone and moved in this direction on us. All the nations are represented in Europe. In America where I'm living now, every nation on earth is represented. Every nation is there, and it's it's a much more complex phenomenon than the fifties style revivalism that could easily reach into American culture where everyone was, well, Anglo Saxon, of Protestant, would think Catholics, you know. But now that's not so. It's very much more different ballgame. But the problem is, again, I want to say that much of our thinking comes from this framework, and much of our forms of attraction evangelism can work. Attractional means, of course, people come to us to hear the gospel, of course, because there's no cultural barrier. But if you're bringing a person to the Lord from over here, and they have to come to... Or they have to, I mean, they go to church because that's the logical place to be nurtured in the faith, And if you're going to church in that regard, well, know, you socialize people in that context, but the problem is you extract them. That's the word. Extract them from that context. The problem is you actually defeat yourself in the long run because the Gospel we know spreads along relational lines. It's a relational issue face to face, right? And we know that's true, and we also know that within three to five years of a person becoming a believer they will no longer have any meaningful relationships with those outside the church. All their meaningful sets of relationships are inside the church. The problem is that if you church them, how do you then reach beyond yourself? And who by the way is doing the missionary work to go to church? Abdul the secular the secular Muslim is now having to learn what goes on here, So he's doing the missionary work. Who are the missionary people of God? That's us. Right? So we're responsible to take the gospel out here. We expect them to come to us. And this is why all forms of it, just merely attraction or let me use the word extraction, I think it's a better word. Extractional evangelism defeats the logic of the gospel in the long run, that it belongs to all the nations. We are responsible to communicate meaningfully. That's the first idea. So I'm just gonna hang that... Keep that in the background, and let's see how we go. So I'm gonna just put that little thing up there. Now I'm gonna... Very quickly, if I can... Tom, what time... I didn't pick up the time on this. Where's Tom? What time did we start? Okay. Good. I'll need... I'll I'll move quite quickly. I wanna use a tool that we we did in Australia. I'm not a statistician nor the son of one. But I was invited to be part of a interpretation group because I'm kinda interest... Very interested in mission with a group called the national church life survey. They had... Came into a lot of money, and they did research on the church every five years like a census, taking a snapshot and comparing statistics. It was very useful for us. It wasn't a pretty picture, I might add, but we're also going down fast. But I don't believe Hillsong on that. Unfortunately, we're not doing that well. But the point being that we... But the best work, I think, was done when they didn't have much to do in between the five years one time, and they did research in what a non believer, a person who self confessedly didn't agree or didn't subscribe to the Christian story, and they did analysis on them. The four areas that they looked at, roughly speaking, was God, Jesus, spirituality, church. Now I'm gonna... I'll I'll give you the the Australian kind of interpretation of it, but I want you to just interact with me from where... Wherever you are in the European experience. Right? So this is positive, that's maybe... That's bad. Okay? So... Okay. When when we asked... They asked these big sample of non Christian people what they thought about God, and this was a surprise for Right? Now let me say this too. They weren't asking about God in holy trinity existing in one person and three persons yet one, all that stuff. Right? Not the Christian understanding necessarily. Generic idea of God, the higher power, he, she, you know, whatever, a force above. When we ask most Aussies what they thought of God, did they believe in God, what do you think they said? Well, let me... Let... Say this for Europeans. This is positives here. Maybes and negatives. Generation. Generationally. But even if you'd average it out, so it's like that or right. Okay. We actually came up quite... I mean, was a shock actually, to be honest. I I didn't think it would be that way. It was up around about the 80 something percent, and and 70 something percent prayed regularly, and we meant by that on a weekly basis. Well, we thought, wow. That's a little... Not... We didn't expect that. When it came to Jesus and and and and the understanding, again, don't think of son of god risen from the dead. Think about Jesus as in his human manifestation. What did most Aussies or what do most Europeans think about Jesus? Positives, maybes, negatives, and, you know, so... Okay. So, you know, again, we were rather surprised, know, think about it in these terms. Right? Who's the greatest person ever lived? Now give me some names here, folks. I'm gonna take a bet where Aussies bet on things. Right? Say, I'm gonna take a bet. Right? He comes up in top three every time. I'm gonna go further and say I'm gonna give you odds to say he's gonna come up number one every time. Right. Okay. Give me some other names. Andy who looks to Jesus. Actually, he will tell you. I found out everything I learned from Jesus leading real Tolstoy's book on the sermon on the mount. Mother Teresa looks to Jesus. Right? I don't even hear that one. Buddha. Buddha. Yeah. Buddha. Actually, it's interesting thing about Buddha whether he's a historical figure or not because it's kind of that mythic thing. Fair enough. Buddha would come up pretty well. It won't probably... I think for most Westerners at least, and I don't mean to be offensive, but it probably is not gonna Mohammed, because the ultimate test is do you wanna go on vacation with Mohammed? Answer is no. Truthfully, you don't. I mean, he had a pretty bad temper, and you likely lose your head. Do you wanna go on vacation with Jesus? I think it'd be a pretty interesting weekend. It might be a challenging time. So actually Jesus comes up pretty well. Spirituality, the search for meaning, significance, purpose, belonging. Most Europeans, do you think it's positive? Maybes? Negatives? No. Actually, again, boy, this is kind of... This... No. This was real, real issue. Most people are on a spiritual quest. They might not be looking in our direction, but they're looking for meaning, purpose, belonging. All those things matter hugely. It's the human issue. Right? It's the human issue. Came up really good. Church in our context. Positives. Any... Anyone wanna say positive? Not one. Maybes? Negatives. No surprises there for us either. We have a whole history there about the convicts thing and all that, and the collaboration of the church and state too. Not good. And the odd odd thing is that we all know that. Right? So here's the thing, the odd situation is that we find a fundamental message, I'm not saying in its finer terms, its dogmatic form, its theological form, but God, Jesus, spirituality, most people think are pretty pretty here, right? When it came down to church, that's the very negative piece, right? So I'll say in business terms if you look in business terms I'll say you've got a darn good product, your delivery system has got problems in it, and if you don't change the delivery system, you're going to be out of business very soon. It's the problem of credibility, a credible witness. The problem is what's going to change? You don't have to change terribly much here, you've got to tell the story in ways that make appeal, but you don't... This has got to change folks, and here we are into the conversation on the missional church. Missional ecclesiology, a church that is designed to deliver its message, and the church and the medium and the message are one. And that's what Jesus intends for the church, we are to be the only place on earth to fully represent the Kingdom of God. Now let me do some further analysis, again that's just another idea I want to just hang in the background, and I'm going to just for the sake of it, don't hear me wrong here, for the sake of analysis, at least for our country, if I took out the church that we know is declining terribly fast, it's the very, very high church, the traditional church, you know, is in serious trouble. So like our uniting church, is a combination of three liberal Protestant denominations, is declining in our country 20% exponentially per annum. 20% exponential per annum decline. That is haemorrhage, and it's doubtful you can turn it around because why? They don't even believe in miracles and it's going to take a miracle to do it. That's a problem, and it is a problem on European theology as well, because you don't believe in miracles much either. You don't believe in them, are you going ever experience one? So let's for the sake of analysis just take it out. What's working in our country apparently is Hillsong, and Hillsong actually is nothing new about it really, it's just basically a derivative of contemporary church growth kind of thinking. So it came out of America. It's it's saddle Willow Creek. Saddleback. Willowback. Right? Willowback. So Willowback's doing quite good in our country. It's carrying much of the challenge of of mission. It's quite vibrant, and you can see in our hillsong forms. It's doing quite well. I'll show you what those are, dude. So so most of our... I was a denominational exec paying for my sins, might add. I found it very difficult kind of work. And and so in our denomination, we didn't have terribly many of these, but if we took them out for analysis, the vast majority of our churches were looking to that model to resolve the problem. Right? So I would say it was... I would say 95% of our churches thought that was it. Now if I put it up against the population of Australia and and use this kind of idea here, and say this form of church in terms of our population, what kind of appeal did it have? Now just to get a feel for this, in our census that is a self defined, you know, the the test that we do on our population, people self define themselves. We had 2.8% evangelical. I use that just as an analysis. Right? I'm saying there are only Christians around, but I'm using that for analysis, and I suspect many of us come from that form. That is the the bible believing crowd, the the kind of charismatic, Pentecostal, and conservative. 2.8% of our population self identifies that way, and that was ten years ago. I don't know what the latest one is. It's gone down, I'm told. So so here we have a situation where we only have about 3% kind of adherence, but I'm gonna say that this form of church, the contemporary church growth model, will relate to our population something like... I'm being generous here. I would say 12 to 15%. Sorry. Can't write at this angle. I think that's kind of our appeal. In America, we... I I... If I tested this out in America, most American churches come back with something like 40%, maybe. And that's been... Again, I'm happy to be very generous. It's 80... In America where I live now, it's 18 attendance any given Sunday, and that right across the board. Okay? So it's not anything in America, 40%. It's cultural appeal, marketability, m zero, m one, that kind of dynamic. Right? So... And here's the thing. It's a declining. In the case of America 40%, declining every year. So here's the situation here, there's two issues that come out, and this is where I want to try and kind of make my point. Two issues arise here, if all the churches think that this is the answer, and it can only ever reach in our context 15 maximizing, does anyone see a problem in that? All our eggs are in the one basket folks. We have no other answer to the missionary challenge of our day other than a variation of Church Growth Theory, Willowback, and variations of it. Multi site is another variation of Willowback. It's fundamentally the same construct paradigm of church. I believe in it, and you know what, in America it still has real vigor. I'm not saying we abandon ship, but folks if all your eggs are in the same basket, that my friends is a big problem, because that means that even if you could get it together and all of us could become like that, you're ever going to reach a limited segment of your population. What do you think it is in Europe? Just give me a do you think it's, like, 12 to 15 here? A contemporary... I guess this is a contemporary expression of church. What do you think the appeal in terms of German population? I don't mean this any... Just give me a... Do you think it's, like, higher or lower? 10%? Maybe. So you see it's a problem. Okay? Now that's one big thing then. That's a that's a huge challenge to to to capture a new imagination of church. Right? Because here... Here's the issue here. Einstein said that the kind of thinking that will resolve the world's problems, I read the church's problem, the kind of thinking that will resolve the church's problems must be of a different order to the kind of thinking that created those problems in the first place. If I said it very much more practically, I'd say it like this. It's called the definition of organizational insanity, guys something like this, that trying to achieve significantly different results but doing the same thing better. Now that's organizational insanity. Now you can improve this, yes, you must. Keep doing it, improving, but trying to achieve significantly different results by doing the same thing better is insane. It doesn't work. You can only better what you're currently doing. So that's the problem. And then secondly, maybe a very, very visual way of saying this, if I wanted to dig a hole over there, it's no good digging a hole over here deeper. And you know the funny thing is we all know that's true, but watch our behaviors, cause it's just one more book from one of those guys who actually run one of these babies, who define what is real and what is successful for us. They print the books, right? They're the successful ones. I know in America it doesn't work for most churches. Here's Leadership Networks kind of analysis of of of this. Right? First and foremost, megachurches, this is three years old, they did research on the growth of the megachurch movement, and they discovered this that there are 1,200 churches in America, greater sorry it's getting messy, greater than 2,000, right, and by the way had doubled in the prior decade to that, right, so it's a growing movement of big churches, but it's 1,200 over 2,000. How many churches in America? 380,000 churches, and their average size is 80. I know that most people can't do it, stats are quite clear about that, right? You do the math on that in terms of the ratio. Most people can't pull this off, whatever it takes to make it happen, most of us can't do it. Timing, situation, resources, all that stuff, right? And the problem is it's quite a costly exercise, can't resolve the problem of America with more of that. It must be part of it, it's bothand, right? You're not going to ditch it. I would argue use this as a platform to launch, so you use what you've got to become what you're not. So movements I think are the answer, right, but that I'm not going there today. I'd love to, but I'm not, because I do think it is the answer. Okay. So that's the one side of the problem, and then the other side of the situation is this is more concerns me deeply, and I'm sure this is, you know, related to those spaces that Martin was talking about. What does the does the church look like here? This is a missionary problem. It's not a strategic problem. Here's the missionary problem. So what about the 85 that are not gonna go there even on your sexiest Sunday? You can you can do kind of, you know, all kinds of razzmatazz and night shows all that. They're not going to come. Here's what we learned from these guys again. There was two sides of the equation in Australia. Right? The one was the kind of blase, good on you mate, not for me, I'm really glad for you, it works for you, but... Right, that's the one side, and then they had no, nay, never. You go to those places, they take your money, mess with your children, can screw up your head, toxic, will not go there. Right? Who's easier to reach you think? I actually find the no nay nevers easier to reach. It's much harder to reach blase people, much harder in my opinion. So we got problems here. So... And I want to spend the rest of the time on this sort of piece of equation. So here's where the idea of medium and message comes. So that's just the background for what I want to say. When... In forge, we kinda teach... We we... We're trying to help Christians think like missionaries in the West. That's a fundamental... To think what it means to actually adopt a missionary stance and take it seriously, to cross the street for some people, you know, to go to where they're at, right? So we teach these things, and I take my cue from this, from a guy who invented the stethoscope. He said, listen, listen, listen to your patients, they're telling you the answer. We still use that sucker today to diagnose people, you know, all that stuff, right? It's still a diagnostic tool. Listen to your patients, they're telling you the answer. We teach our people fundamentally two things, right? And it's much more than that, but it boils down to these two things. And you can only answer these questions once you get there. You've got to go to the, whatever, on the side, in our case, 85% of Australians. You have to go among them, and only once you're there, two questions have to be answered. What is good news for this people group? What's going to sound like, yes, good news. Right? And the other one is what is church? Because we can't presume that the way we do church now is gonna work. You know, I've already made that case. Right? So so what is church? How would how would that look like among the 85% of Europeans who won't go to our best expressions? So let me do this first one, and here I want to take us very much focused on our most fundamental message of the Gospel of Jesus Christ, is that what is good news? I say this with great sense of respect, I'm in Germany, it's now heading up to the five hundred years of the Reformation next year, so I say with respect. But if the only tool that you've got is a hammer, then everything looks like a nail. Right? Do you know that's true? So if so if the only tool that you've got is a hammer, then everything looks like a nail. The problem us us Protestants, we've been deeply and profoundly scripted by the justification by faith narrative. You can call it this way. Christendahl talks about the introspective consciousness of the West, the guilt consciousness of the West. It's deep within the Western understanding of ourselves. Right? So here's the story. So Luther was an Augustinian monk in medieval Europe. He was a godly man. He loved God. He wanted to relate to God, but in medieval Europe, God was always seen as distant, so you had all those layers of intercessory kind of layers of mediators between you and God, and even Jesus Christo Ponta Cratur, if you go into your cathedrals, you'll see him sitting right at the top and underneath him, angels, and then the saints and Mary and all that stuff, and he comes down and there's me, and then there's hell below, you know, that hierarchical view of the universe, right? So he would look at that and think about God and thinking, Oy vey, Jewish expression, but I'm lost, there's no way that I can please that God. And so he begins to tussle with Paul's writings, right? How can the righteousness of God be any good news to us? Until he realizes actually it's a gift. It's to be received by faith. You don't do it by works. So this is Paul's... And it releases the reformation, which is the revolution, right? Powerful idea. But here's the thing folks, I mean, was a guy who had experienced his own guilt deeply. Augustinian monks, kind of like the Calvinists, you know, high view of God, low view of humanity. So he was terrified. He would think about God and have his Right? How did I do? Is like a panic attack. It's like... I've had one recently. I must have been very tired. I thought I dying. I thought I I was... I... Yeah. It's a nice story. I got into the backseat of the car, I thought my wife and her sister were sitting in the front, I thought, I'm just gonna die quietly in the corner. It was an interesting experience, actually, because I thought, what? I was embarrassed about it. It was bizarre. But anyway, he would have these hyperventilates. Listen, when you have one, just put a paper bag over your mouth. You'll be alright. It feels like you're dying, but you're fine. And so I did that. Anyway, he would think about God and have a panic attack. Right? And he and he discovers this justification by faith, gift to be received. Now the focus is... Now now and I've squared notes if you doubt my unorthodox in this, you know, evangelical terms with Keller on this because Keller very... Tim Keller has got a very similar understanding on this. So we've... I'm writing with him at the moment, sir. And so so Tim Keller would say, how many people do you think in New York City, billion or on or wherever where we at, how many people in your city are having Anfechtoun today? Five, six maybe? I don't know, not too many, right? Because it's a different universe, right? They don't think about God and tremble. If they think about God at all, it's a very different set of criteria, right? It's that if the only tool that you've got is a hammer, then everything looks like an else. So the problem is if the only tool you've got is justification by faith, and just so that you don't misunderstand me, I believe in it. I'm a sinner. Jesus has provided for me an atoning death. I'll take it anyway. I mean, people argue about the atonement, I'll have it any way God wants to give it. Seriously. Whatever way he wants to, I'll have it. Right? So I don't doubt it. Right? But the problem is if I... The only tool I've got is that. When I approach the modern city, and the situation we find ourselves in, that's the only script I've got, then guess what? I've got to make people feel bad about themselves before they can feel good, so I end up as the tongue plucking faracy. Hello? That's what we look like in America, the moralistic, life denying, because we have to make people feel bad before they can introduce them to Jesus. By the way, that's the work of the Holy Spirit, who will convict us of sin and righteousness. Not your work, you usually suck at it, as do I. You can be a good news person, you don't have to make people feel bad about themselves. You can have an opinion without being moralistic. You can witness to another life, right? So I want to relieve you of that in Jesus name you do not have to be a Pharisee. Stop it. You're actually blocking the gospel. So here, how do you approach the city? Observe their sin. Their sin is a direct clue to what they think is important. GK Chesterton no less said this, that the man knocking on the door of a brothel is looking for God. Oh, he thought, well, take the moralistic stand, oh that's very bad behaviour, right, it is, right? It's immoral, but listen to what is being said there. What do you think when a person goes to a brothel to pay for sex, what do you think they're looking for? Transcendence, give me some more. Relationship. It's a very... Man, human appetite will be served, denied food, it'll gobble poison. Right? It's not a perfect form of food, but it's a grasp at it. Orgasm is the idea of just being raised above my miserable existence, all that. Just for a moment, even the poor can experience it. God bless God for that. It's just a little bit of transcendence in a kind of very, escape, touch, embrace. These are human issues, right? The existential issues. And here's the thing, what's the Gospel going to say about that? I would say quite a lot, right? C. S. Lewis said that all our vices are virtues gone wrong. All our vices are virtues gone wrong. We're looking for the right thing in the wrong place. So they're looking for human touch connection, but they're doing it in the wrong form, but it's the right motivation folks. Can we at least affirm that? Look at people's idolatry when someone gives their life to their job or to money, which I think is a terrible, terrible idol, will destroy your life because as soon as your bank's zero, bank balance is zero, you are a zero. And that's why people taught themselves, you know, suicide when... Because when their bank balance goes down, that's how they measure their self worth. Can you at least say then that idols, at least when when people are worshipping something that is false, at least it's a clue to what they think is important. Can you not at least acknowledge that and bring a gospel message to bear on that? What you're looking for there my friends, you can find fulfilment here. What about shame and honour? This is increasingly a big issue, right? Because we live in an oversexualised culture. In America I think shame is deep within the culture. Now a gospel of justification by faith does not address shame narratives. God is the lifter of our heads. You can't address that with justification by faith. It's dealing with a different experience than the human condition called guilt before a holy God. Shame is a different thing entirely, it's experienced differently. God raises up the downcast, he brings down the pride, pride and shame go together. The Gospel has a lot to say about that folks, it does, but you can't address it with just the simple Jesus died for me narrative. It's a kingdom, you're bringing a different story to bear on that. We need to learn the nuance that is in the gospel itself, and by the way, the Bible itself says more about shame and honor than it does about guilt and righteousness. And I'm not dismissing it, I'm just simply saying we've just scripted that out of the equation because we've only got one tool. What about and I've often... I don't know if this is entirely true, but it's increasingly true across the world where the... You could say there are like three. In the West we deal with right and wrong, right, or righteousness or guilt, and all that's associated with guilt consciousness. In the East what are the big issues in culture? Honour and shame. Right? Honour and shame are big in The Middle East and in the East, the face, Facebook is a big shaming culture, and this is not just in the East anymore. Sports is a classic shame and honor. The champion is the one who's honored. Everyone else is shamed. We live in a highly competitive world. What does the gospel say about that? Gee, actually I'll tell you what, says a lot. There's a German name, Werner Mischke, has written a really excellent book on the shame and honor called The Global Gospel. It's excellent, and increasingly it's the issue of honor and shame over here. In Africa or in the South it's power, powerlessness primarily. You can't address an African existential experience with a Western kind of rational one. You have to address the issue of power and powerlessness. It's a different register for the gospel. You with me? And I can go on about this stuff, right? What about drugs? Another way. What is being sought when people kind of take a toke on a joint or do other drugs, right? What's being sought there? I was a drug addict so I can say this right. It's being sought as this desire to transcend again, so this desire to ecstasy, the idea of being lifted above my misery, and the other one is to avoid pain, to my suffering, my anxiety, so that's more the heroine, the downers, right? Again, what does the Gospel say about that, and how can we address that issue in our day? Like I said, I can go on. I just think we need to return again to our most fundamental message, and not just see it in one singular term. All our problems that I would argue in the church, all of them are reductions of the great truth that is much bigger. Reductionism is our big problem, folks. We reduce it down to one singular thing and make it the whole, and then make everyone conform to that. Put it back up there in the big grand story of God's redemption of the world and dealing with every aspect of human sin and brokenness and bringing redemption to all things. It's a much bigger enterprise than we could ever imagine. So if we claim to be evangelical, we define ourselves by the gospel. Gee, folks. Let's big. There's a whole group in America who define themselves called the Gospel Coalition. I don't even mind naming them there because they reduce it down to an atonement theory and then make everyone say that's the only gospel. It's a damaging thing folks, and then they politicise it and make everyone, you know, if you don't use the gospel the way we use it, you are this and that. It's wrong. Bigger, not smaller, bigger. Don't diminish that narrative, put it in its grander context. Covenant and kingdom, not just covenant. The Bible is much bigger than just one singular like narrative, so repent, because that's kairos, right? Bigger. I don't know if I said that, but so the final one is enough, I've got no time left to explore this deeply, but if what is gospel is our primary thing, if that's the message, what is the medium? What is the church? You don't know till you get there. Remember we're going to a context. You can't front load your ecclesiology, your understanding of church in that equation, and force it to fit. You can't take Lutheran churches to Africa, and then make... Know, I've seen this actually, the poor guy was like in high Lutheranness. I don't mean no offense, right? But you've front load your ecclesiology, so you've got Gothic cathedrals, it doesn't snow there, so you don't need that vaulted ceiling at all. Then all the stuff, right, doesn't work in Europe anymore, but we're gonna take it to Africa. Right? So we actually say our church model is first. So now the thing is, no, you go there first, and you... Actually, I would suggest you plant the gospel. You plant the gospel and implant the Jesus story and let the church grow out of its encounter with Jesus Christ. It's going to look different in Africa. It's going to look different in all the different subcultures and all the cultures that are in Germany or in Europe. It's got to be. There's no singular form. Because if there was only one form, folks, you know what? The Jews were right. And then let me tell you guys, this is the whole Galatian issue. Right? This is not good news for you, because I'm gonna say, like, repent and be baptized is pretty... It's a challenge, right? Repent and be circumcised, it's a hard sell. Right? But if if if we say the forms of the church are not adapted, there's nothing sacred about the forms of the church, nothing. It's a highly adaptive phenomenon because it's a human institution, it's a human agency, that is it exists in a certain time, among a certain people, it's different among different times and places, because we're not Muslims, we don't believe that you have to be the original form, it translates into different settings. In other words, the church is a highly adaptive institution, highly adaptive, and we need to learn to ask what is church, but you only know it once you get there, follow the entrails, go to where people are, and then you insinuate the church. What does ecclesia look like here? There are some principles that you can follow, but you don't front load your previous form on it. I'll finish off now, just to say this: we are living in a kind of critical time, but I'm also very excited about it because we are in that kind of grand moment where we are facing an adaptive challenge and we are now aware of the problem. But I want to just say is that let's dream again with our primary story, really think big about what God wants to do, and what God is already doing in culture. Can we join with him, and find the spaces where people can come to know a genuine encounter with the gospel in Jesus Christ. God bless you, my friends, and I'm there with you. Yeah. I wanna help you. Thank you.