Address
Collective 2021 - Session 2 - Four Fulcrums for System-wide Change - Alan Hirsch
Alan Hirsch
Transcript
Transcript of the recording.
Hi there. It's just great to be here with you even if it is in a strange medium like this rather than a physical conference at the tops. But a wonderful opportunity to be with you here. Thanks to Andrew and the team for the invite. It's been a long time since I've addressed my own denomination in any way, so it's a particular honor. I also wanna just give thanks for Andrew and Wendy for their years of great service to the conference. I mean, I think it's been quite a long time, and they've done a great job. And, you know, all credit to you guys. God bless you and your and your choices in the future. A few years ago, I had the opportunity to read a book by a guy called Joshua Cooper Ramo. A very cool name. And the book's name was called the age of the unthinkable. And Kuparama was a Times correspondent for many, many years, and he now heads up Kissinger and Associates, the geopolitical strategic advisory firm. Kissinger, you know that one. And so he's a very smart guy. And the book really is a book about the conditions of rapid change that we face ourselves in and how do we respond to it. And early on in the book, he uses a metaphor of a sandpile. Now I want you to think about the last time you went to a beach or when you were a kid or whatever, and you went down, you took a bucket of sand, and you poured it out onto, you know, say, a platform of some sort, and then you put another bucket. It just... It develops into a kind of pyramid. Right? You put another bucket of sand on it, it goes up, you know, to pyramid, and it begins to peak the more you begin to put it on. And eventually, it comes to a point when the the sand pile is particularly unstable. And this is of a great interest to scientists and chaos theory. It's good about density and mass, all that stuff. I have no idea about it. But it's a very unstable kind of kind of situation. And, theoretically, if just one little grain of sand and you can see it coming down in slow motion hits the top of the the sand pile when it's on... You know, unstable, it can reset the whole sand pile. And he uses this... I think it's a very powerful metaphor for the world in which we live in. A world in which, you know, everything's connected. A world in which small actions in one part of the the planet can actually have great ramifications in in the other part of the planet. And as as we're well aware of, you know, even in terrorist actions can change the course of history, even it's a relatively small action. But but the main thing here is I want you to feel the metaphor with me. You feel like me that we're living in a sandpile world. We're just we're just about to be retriggered in something. And I think that actually that's why it's a very powerful metaphor because I think it really is something that really applies to our situation. Now Cooperama's idea is that in such a situation, if we take ideas that were formulated in a different set of circumstances, a completely different time and a different place, and apply these ideas willy nilly to the situation which we find ourselves in, these will call... Cause more problems than they resolve. And this happens all the time. Now for instance, the Iraq war, which he quotes is one of the examples. But what was happening in the Iraq war is that the American government at the time was influenced by a thing called neoconservatism. And the neoconservatives believe that if you could bring democracy to the Middle East, which had no tradition of democracy, by the way. So if we could bring democracy there and establish it in in in the Middle East, it'll bring down basically the dictatorships, and we'd establish a more stable kind of society. The problem is that the democracy they had in mind was American democracy, nineteenth century style democracy, which is barely working in America as it's very evident at the moment. And we're gonna take that, and we're export it to the Middle East. And now we're still dealing with the problem. You know, I I believe that, you know, ISIS is probably a direct result of attempting to do that. So, again, trying to apply ideas and formulate it in a different time in in this tricky kind of sandpile world we live in creates more problems than resolve. The truth is, folks, is that the church does this all the time. We are constantly using ideas that were formulated in different epochs, different times of the church, and then applying them today with expecting kind of, you know, the same results. But, of course, that is insanity. It doesn't work like that. Right? For us as church of Christ, it might be like nineteen thirties style taint evangelism. But if you're... Something like a reformed folk, you go back to the sixteenth century or eighteenth century, whatever it is that where we, you know, we draw our ideas from. The problem is that we're formulated for completely different set of circumstances. And then, of course, comes the... What I call the COVID apocalypse. And as a apocalyptic revelatory event, COVID pandemic has exposed deep and systemic flaws or fragility in our systems and the systems of the church. And the truth is, folks, that the church has been in a rut for a long, long time, and we somewhat over relied on methodologies that derive from a different time, different place. Mainly, we have a Sunday service emphasis. And we... We've seen this as the biblical way until, of course, the apocalypse comes and shows us that it actually been... We're pretty fragile and dependent on certain ways of doing things. I have a little kind of suggestion to make. If you want to learn how to play chess, take out your queen first. And your opponent will keep their queen, and they're going to cream you for a long, long time. But what's gonna happen is that without your queen, you're going to have to learn what the other pieces on the chess board can do. You learn to really play chess without the queen. Eventually, you can put your queen back in, and you really will learn how to play chess properly because you learn what the whole game of chess is about. And I think we're kind of in one of those moments. We've we've over relied on certain functions or kind of methods and approaches, and now we're having to find other aspects of the church that kinda gonna bring into the game and bring us strength. And now your survival, I believe, is their very survival is a viable local church is at stake. And so in this situation, as Doug Paul is gonna be telling you, and every one of us must become an innovator. We must become innovators. I had an experience once where I was talking, but roughly a similar kind of kind of idea. And I was cornered literally by three... I can sort of remember this very clearly. Three very big Southern Baptist kind of dudes. And they literally had me in the corner, and they, you know, poking my chest and saying, Alan, you're saying we're all innovators. We're not all innovators, are we? Of course, I was meant to say, no. I'm not. I said, oh, well, you know, maybe... But, you know, unless your life depended... Depended on that. If your life depends on it, friends, you can be very innovative indeed. Human beings have got real capacity for innovation given the right circumstances, And I believe we're in one of those moments now. This conference actually has been very cleverly named to the idea of fulcrum, and Andrew's described why why he used that. It's a very, very clever kind of concept. In the various forums that I'm involved in and the ones that I lead, we talk about finding the meta ideas and leveraging these ideas to change the system. Now meta idea, you know, way of thinking are the important foundational ideas, cornerstone concepts, primordial principles. You know, they... They're very important centers of of thinking that control other ways of thinking. So they're also what are called recalibration centers. They're recalibration points because they basically allow us to reset or reboot to the more original settings of the church. Now Andrew's calling these, you know, fulcrums, and I think it's the same idea. It's the finding the place of maximum leverage. Archimedes, the kind of the philosopher mathematician, said, if I had a lever long enough, I could move the world. If I had a lever long enough, I could move the world. And that's the idea of fulcrum. Right? Eighty twenty principle. We... 20% of effort creates 80% of results. Very strategic. Many times we do church in what we call the twenty eighty principle, where a whole lot of stuff our efforts about 80% of effort is put in to produce 20% effectiveness. And we're not the most efficient system in town, and it's very expensive generally, for what we achieve. So so my experience is that when churches find these primordial principles, leverage points, fulcrums, and they can activate them, then they come alive again. Like, a real possibility of change. So I'm going to suggest in this talk that there are four areas, four fulcrums that you can leverage in order to change your system. These are, again, dense recalibration points, theological centers. Change here changes everything. Change at at at a focal point changes everything. So they are gonna be very quickly. I'll outline them for you. Is there are rejesus that is a a return to the absolute centrality of the person of Jesus for the life of the church and the life of the Christian. Two, redisciple, the recovery of discipleship as a strategic activity, remission as in shaping the way we engage in our culture and going out and going deep, and reorganizing, which really has to do with forms and how do we express ourselves in local churches. These big ideas, and I can only point them out to you here, and I hope that this stimulates you to think and study a bit more about them for the Fresh Hope churches. I think we're now in a situation where we literally have to think differently about ourselves. So I suggest these are really important areas. So fulcrum number one, read Jesus. William Temple said that if your conception of God is radically false, then the more devout you are, the worse it'll be for you because you're opening your soul to be molded by something else. The the archbishop says, you would much better be an atheist. But think about what he's saying there is if your concept of God is wrong, then the more devout you are about that wrong idea of God, the more dangerous you are to other people. It's much better you don't believe it all. I actually think he's correct, and I think... Well, you know, CSO says, of all the the charlatans in history, the religious ones are the worst. Now... So the question now arises, how do we know we've got God right? How can we be sure that we got the right concept of God? Right? And I wanna suggest you that it's... It is is Christology. It is the person of Jesus. Is the only place that we can be sure that we have got God correct is when we're looking and and and engaging with the person of Jesus Christ who, being the son of God and their being one, is the perfect reflection of who God is. These Christology friends, everything about Jesus, and not some other recalibration center that lies at the absolute heart of the renewal of the church in any time and in any place we find ourselves in. If we get stuck, if we're not sure what it's all on about or what's church all on about and where are we going, what's it about, then I suggest to you that we go back to the founder of the faith, of Christianity, Christ himself, in order to know ourselves. So I call the re Jesus effect. You're going back to Jesus to to to talk to Jesus for the checkup. The question is, where else do you go if it's not Jesus? How else do you know whether you are on the correct path or not, whether you're Christian or not? What other place do you go back to to know whether you're a you're a church legitimately? I live I live in America and here part time now, but we've lived in America for the last thirteen years. And I can say without qualification that the most important recalibration facing the American church at the moment, American evangelicalism particularly, is recalibration around the central person of the faith, Jesus Christ. This is not a political statement. I could care less for the politics, but the contemporary evangelical church seems to me simply does not seem to properly and rightly represent Jesus in his way particularly well at all at the moment. When we look and study what Jesus did, what he taught, what he what he objectively demonstrated to us and commanded us to do, when we look down that angle and we then look at the church and how it behaves, you'd have to really wonder whether they are the same phenomenon that we're looking at. If... And here's the thing is what I've come down to. If the church does not look, act, think, and feel like Jesus, then it's probably not the church. If it doesn't look, act, and think like Jesus, it's probably not the church because the church has to embody who Jesus is and what he's on about in the world. And I said this with all technical kind of accuracy. If Jesus isn't found in the life of our churches, then what the hell are we doing? Literally. If you claim to be evangelical and believe in the bible and all that stuff, but you don't look and act and sound like Jesus, then you really have to think again. This is where that recalibration joint point comes in. Jesus changes everything, friends, and we need to recalibrate back to him. Change here changes everything. It's a fulcrum, remember. Fulcrum number two, redisciple. The funny thing is that in spite of how central discipleship is to New Testament Christianity, I have found that most churches in the Western church suck at it. They really don't even know what... You know, most people ask, well, what is discipleship and how you do it? Of all the things we've chosen to forget, it's discipleship, which is the great mandate of the church. Most of us are more about believing certain doctrinal ideas and attending worship services, but we really don't know how to do the discipleship thing very well. But friends, discipleship is utterly essential. And why is that the case? Because discipleship is how Jesus gets into the church. It's literally the idea where we take Jesus seriously enough to engage him, embody him, and and to reflect him in the world. It goes back to that original thing about we're Jesus. Right? So let's get some definitions going down. Just a few ideas about what discipleship is. So some some biblical terminology, imitation of Christ. I should become more and more and more and more and more and more and more like Jesus every year. I should be more like Jesus this year than I was last year, and I should be heading in that direction. Imitation of Christ. Confirmation that our lives are to be indexed to the person of Jesus Christ. There's meant to be some sort of correlation between us. Christ, body of Christ. Christ, Christian. Transformation. We're being transformed into his image from one degree of glory to another. This is from the lord who is the spirit. We're becoming more and more and more like Jesus as we look upon his face, says Paul in second Corinthians. There's the ideas of union with Christ, which is Paul's idea of in Christ theology. You've got the abiding in Christ idea. It's very Jesus saturated affair, friends. Discipleship is everything about Jesus. My eternal destiny is to be conformed to his image, says Paul in Romans eight twenty eight. And our mission and our ministry is to extend the mission and ministry and impact of Jesus in the world, and discipleship takes it seriously. A very easy definition, discipleship is doing the same kinds of things that Jesus did for the same kinds of reasons that he did that. So, folks, I suggest you that in terms of leverage point, we need to raise the bar on discipleship. We should put that up, ratchet it up to a higher level, and and learn how to make disciples in in our churches. And we should lower the bar on how church is done. The way we... At the moment, we tend to do it is the other way around. We make church a very complicated affair that it takes seven years of study, praise be to God, to to actually be able to lead one of those suckers. How does that make even sense in the New Testament? And secondly, we make... We put discipleship as an optional extra and put tendons there in its place. It's just not good enough. And if we're going to have to, you know, be faithful to Jesus in this time, discipleship has to become critical in the in the game. So much is built into it. It's our capacity to embody Jesus in the world and and to bring credibility to the message and our witness, which is the basis of authority, which in that spiritual authority is the basis of leadership. If you suck at discipleship, you should suck at leadership because you haven't got Christ like leaders to draw upon. And so, really, everything builds on this. And therefore, it's a, you know, it's a it's a key idea. Nondiscipleship, friends, undermines everything else we seek to do. Dallas will not equate insight. And so we need to correct our nondiscipleship. Change here changes everything. It's a fulcrum. Fulcrum number three, remission. Remission. In a time when the church was privileged and was the central religious institution in society, which has been predominant of Western society from the 300 to roughly the seventeenth, eighteenth centuries, but has been still primary way the church operates. When the church was the central religious institution, you could operate as if when people came to the Lord, they just come to church in order to kind of hear the message and hear and and and be developed in the fact. It's what we call attraction. Right? And this is fine because the vast majority of of people in the western settings were Christian by birth, and there weren't any other options anyway. But this is not really what the bible means by mission. I mean, you can do this, but it's not everything. Right? Particularly when you're in a missionary environment. Just to to remind us of this, that's the Latin term. For the biblical term is apostela, which is the root word of the word apostle, the sent one. But is... Literally means sent. It's the root of the word missile. If you wanna send us, I just don't wanna receive it. So missio means sent. It's go to them. Right? It's not just come to us. You know, we make much in in in evangelical circles of Matthew's great commission, and so we should. But, actually, is it one that I think that we we tend to forget and and to to our detriment is that... Is the... What we call the Jonah commission in John. John twenty twenty one says this. Jesus says this, just as the father sent me, so I send you. So sickness, we get it. It's repeated twice, that word. Going out, going outward bound. We're being sent into the world. Right? We feel the pressure of that. But but the other side of it is just as the father sent the son. How does the father sent the son? Incarnation. And so we have to go in the way of incarnation. Incarnation means we go deep into culture. We go deep in bits. So if if the one is about going, the other one's about staying and embodying in a way that makes sense in a given situation. It's more the contextualization thing. And the two of them go together. The pattern of scripture is going out, going deep, going out, going deep, going out, going deep. And both of them are necessary. And this is not just important practice in the missionary environment which we find ourselves in the West and in Australia. But I would suggest that our deepest theology must inform our best methodology. The theology of Missio Dei, that God is a missionary God, and that's... Must... And then, of course, the incarnation, which is a very, very important aspect of Christian theology, informs our patterns, our way of going about in the world we go, outgoing deep in the way of Jesus. And here here, I believe, is the primary pattern that we need to recover. Again, this is a fulcrum area. It's a leverage point. It's a matter idea. Change here changes everything. Finally, fulcrum number four. And I call this reform, but you can call it reorganized, but reform is really probably enough for us now. This has to do more with organizational capacity and our forms and expressions of the church. And just just the thing about forms. Forms really are our our capacity to create culture and and express them in different ways. So, you know, it's just a different cultural kind of techniques and ways of doing things. I said this... Someone who's really trying to study this very deeply is that ecclesiology in the bible is an essential doctrine. It's not like something you can you can opt out of. There's no such thing as an unbaptized Christian. That you are... Once you... A Christian, you're baptized into the body of Christ. Like it or not, suck it up. We're gonna have to deal with the church. There's nothing wrong with that. It's God's plan. Church is essential in God's plan. We don't get to opt out of it. But of all the biblical doctrines, it's the most fluid of the doctrines. Why? Because the church is a historical entity. It exists in a certain time. Church is a cultural entity. It exists in a certain place. And therefore, in different times and different places, we're going to be different, and we need to be because the forms of the church change depending on on situations. So let me play this out. You don't need to speak Greek or Latin to be a church. You don't have to follow the order... Any order of service to be in a church. There's no set one that the bible sets you. You don't need buildings of a peculiar shape to be a church. You don't need to wear funny clothes from medieval Europe to be a church. These are all forms. And and here's the thing, If you can have all these forms and expressions, there's nothing wrong with them, then you need to invent a whole lot more, as I suggest you will need to, different ways of expressing. Please just don't make them sacred. Don't put them beyond the the the the capacity to be changed and to be adapted to different situations. Don't become so attached to them that you can't let go of it. And one thing of the great reformation, there's lots of... Some things are not so great about it, but but one of the things I really think that is very useful about the reformation is they gave us a formula called ecclesia semper reformanda. And it goes like this, that the church reformed, that once the church is reformed, reformatted, if you will, the church reformed ought always to be reforming according to the word of god. So you got like here, you're gonna look at the church,
you look at the word, you look at the church, you look at the word,
look at the church with the word and say, I think there's still some stuff we gotta learn. We haven't arrived at perfection. Keep reforming. It's a pity actually that the protest movement didn't follow that terribly well. We get stuck in eighteenth century and nineteenth century, really twentieth century falls. And this is part of our problem is that we haven't stuck with the principle of keep reforming. So I would suggest... Again, I don't have time for this, but it's been the passion of my whole lifetime study is the issue of movements. But I would suggest you that the alternative way of thinking about ourselves in this time, and one that will take us into the future, is the idea of apostolic movement. Rather than being a static church that requires, you know, all kinds of institution and peep... Drawing people to it, we need to be a people that move and more agile. We need to think like a movement. We need to begin to organize like a movement, and therefore, we'll be able to perhaps have the impact of the movement. So movement thinking is very, very important. And, again, I don't have any time in this kind of talk to go much deeper than I wrote. Forgotten ways to deal with that one, but... Which is a very thick the way. But I would really encourage people to think differently. It's a different paradigm of the way of thinking. But one aspect of movement thinking that I think I can mention over here, it's only brief mention, but is the the idea of the apeist typology of ministry, which is the Ephesians four typology, the five whole ministry of apostle, prophet, evangelist, shepherd, teacher, given to all the church in the ascension of Jesus as he goes up. He commissions his church. He gives in the ascension five fundamental functions to the church to be embodied by the body of Christ in his commissioning. And these are... All five are necessary. So in terms of movement thinking, you need all five to both... You need missional ministry to both initiate and sustain movement. To initiate that is to generate new forms and then to maintain integrity, and then on the other hand, to sustain them. And that that, I would argue, it needs APE to generate S and T to to sustain and make it operative and make it better. Now I don't believe in silver bullets. It's like, you know, the one thing that just changes everything that's gonna heal all your problems. But, darn, I think it gets very, very close to being a silver bullet. And so I recommend it to you for your study. And it just needs to be recovered. It was already there in your church. Remember, it's a it's a a fulcrum, so change here changes everything. And so we come to the end of the talk. I'm also aware that it can feel somewhat overwhelming. But I believe with my heart that you will recognize these patterns as something implicit in scripture and as true, and your heart will know it is true, and you will resonate with them. When when there's a call to recover the absolute centrality of Jesus, It's something you should easily recognize as something that's important for the faith. There's a call to recover discipleship and disciple making as core functions of the church, and to to put them in this... And and and and spend time and and resources on making sure it happens is absolutely critical. And I think your heart will tell you that. There's a call to recover incarnational forms of mission as we find ourselves increasingly in a missionary environment to go out and go deep. And there's a call to recover the more fluid and dynamic movement of form of the church along with the fivefold ministry, which, again, is gonna get strong biblical resonance to it or it ought to have. These should not be strange to you, and in fact, should be instincts that are latent in you and in every one of God's people and in all the churches that we happen to lead. They can, and they must be recovered if we are to be faithful in this time. Awaken them. Jesus has given you everything you need to get the job done. All you need to do is awaken them. Now finish with just this idea. It'll... It's a challenging idea, but I think it sits well as a metaphor that the ships ships are safest when they're in the port, but that's not what ships were made for.