Conversation
Emerging Apostolic Movements and Strategies Today with Alan Hirsch & John Kelly | Bridge Summit 2019
Alan Hirsch
Transcript
Transcript of the recording.
So I think they'll be fine.
Okay. Mark, that was really insightful. That was really good. That's the difference between brother, father, family. It's excellent. Praise god. Oh, yeah. Thanks, Brian.
So
while we're hooking things up here, I mentioned to you about the the annual International Congress of the International Coalition of Apostolic Leaders. And our... Basically, our theme this year is master builders, that apostolic leaders are to be master builders. And that that is a distinction, and many say the distinction of the apostle is signs, wonders, healing, deliverance, and so forth. But that's the signs of a believer. That's the sign of all within the fivefold ministry. And, by the way, on a side note, there is a difference between apostles and the exercise of spiritual gifts, and that is that all the fivefold can cast out demons. How many would give me an amen on that? But don't forget, apostles cast out people. They used to call it excommunication. So I wouldn't spread that around too much. I just thought I'd have a little fun with you all. But here is a form for those of you that are interested in coming to the to the gathering. It's October 28 to November 1, and it begins actually at 09:00 in the morning on the twenty ninth. It goes all day and all evening, and the same thing with the thirtieth all day and all evening, and on the thirty first all day and all evening. And, so it's a fly in event. Probably 95% or more of those coming are flying in, and it's gonna be at the Hyatt Regency in the middle of the airport. And they're coming from Central, South Asia. The South Pacific will be there. The Caribbean will be there. The Central America, South America, Africa, will all be represented there. And, we have one section on master building of local churches and the different methods that are used. And the same thing with apostolic networks and also other things as well that we'll be talking about. We'll be talking about what's an apostolic hub or center and and what is what is biblical on that, what is not. There's some models that I think that are being done where someone like myself that has an office in their house and maybe an administrator and they're calling themselves an apostolic center. I think an apostolic center takes a little bit more than that. So, you know, we'll we'll be going into all those different things as well. So this is for that. This will give you all the information on booking your hotel, on the... And it also comes in Spanish and also Portuguese as well. And so this is all that you need. And Lynn has... Lynn, let everybody see us. She's the the bird with the broken wing back there. Hallelujah. So so she has these if you want them. If not, you can just go on internationalcoalitionofapostolicleaders.com. I see. I see a leaders? Or icaicalleadersin.com, and that also comes up. Okay? Thank you. So Alan Hirsch and I, we're here to share some things. And I think I wanna begin with something I find very interesting, and that is that one of the things that that I see is that no one in the New Testament was called to a local church. Now we hear that, you know, I'm called to this church or that church as ministers and all that. And I think... I'm not I'm not saying that that's wrong, but I'm just saying it's limited. And I think it causes our our vision and our scope of seeing things from an apostolic perspective to be somewhat skewed because in in my understanding of scripture, they were either called to a city or they were called to a territory. In other words, they were called to a place. And so therefore, you're called to be an apostle, prophet, evangelist, pastor, teacher to a place that that in... That involves not only the redeemed of the Lord, but also the unredeemed as well. And so we have a role in function in society in penetrating various, spheres that are with... Within within culture. So I... I'd like you to share some views on that.
Yeah. We we just, caught up over lunch, and this is one of the topics that did come up. And, I'm currently working with, a group called City to City, which is... It originates in New York, Tim Keller, who have a very strong commitment to city building and and and tackling the issue of the city, which I think is... We we affirm is something very, very important. But But I'd never really noticed that no one has particularly ever called not to a city per se, you know, or not to a to a church, but to a city because I think it's really quite liberating idea. But going back to the idea we talked about before, I think partly we have a very narrowed understanding of what it means to be the church, which I think goes to this issue. We talked about the fact that ecclesia ecclesia, the kind of term that is the... One of the base terms in the New Testament is not... Is really a term that was taken from broader society as part of the very structures of society, which the elders of the city exist for the benefit of the city. So even in the very use of the name that the church exists for the benefit, not just for the insiders, but also for those beyond beyond itself. And the other thing I would simply add to that, John, and and I'd be interested in your take on this is that it seems to me that that that we... We've we've been captured to a very narrow understanding of the church. The word ecclesia could... As far as I can determine, there's, like, number of levels. So, like, the first level would be the ecclesia that meets in Chloe's house. Right? So that's the house church level. That's the basic unit, and it... This... The word is used of that unit. Then there's the church in the city. So the church in Corinth or in Ephesus, there's... Now it covers a much bigger ground. Then you got the church in Cappadocia, you know, the whole regional. Same word, interestingly. And then I think the other one I think you can discern in the scriptures is the invisible church, the theological identity, you know, the identity in Christ which encompasses them all. And it seems to me that we've we've limited the word church down to the merely local or the merely, you know, theological, but we've actually lost our capacity to operate here, which is where the apostolic particularly abides because the apostolic ministry is particularly translocal ministry. It exists beyond the local, as well as including the local. So I think that's, you know, something there. Our terminology is limited in our capacity to understand our functions.
I was, with a group, and they were talking about... It was a roundtable discussion on the apostolic. And, their view had a lot to do with resourcing and and helping pastors. And so I... In my mind, I see that as more of a pastoral model, and and I believe as apostles, we should be shepherds. So so there's nothing wrong with that. What what I would see as wrong with that is the limitation that they put on it. And so one of the things I brought up when when I was sharing was the whole point of warfare and that the the main role of the apostle overall is to lead the church in the warfare of heavenly... Of the heavenly and the earthly realm. And and it's been doing a great job in the heavenly realm, you know, functioning in a priestly role, prophetic role, intercession, all that revelation and all. But not so well in the earthly realm being, you know, reformers, reconcilers, restorers, you know, in in that realm. And so, and I also made the comment, if there's no war, then start one. You know, that's... And and so we are actually... We're talking about raising up churches, and we're talking about sending, but we're sending people into the world to do to do a warfare. I would like your...
Yeah. I thought it was, again, good a good point. And, again, I think that there are... Those other functions of looking after congregations is totally appropriate. But I think the... You know, this is where the fivefold becomes really very useful for us, I think, in that, you know, there are people who are looking after the, you know, the... As a flourishing human community, you know, which is gonna... The past of the shepherd. And it's necessary. And it's necessary. And and it's home based ministry. So... Yeah. But, again, we've limited down. Mhmm. So I I I like the idea of, like, generalship or the idea of strategy or how do you actually transform whole cultures, which requires a different strategy than the one you'd use locally. So I'd appreciate more from you on that just, you know, because I think, you know, you've had much more of, you know, a very active role, you know, globally on that
experiencing that in in in a different way. I think it has to do with the way you prepare generations. And, you said something I... You know, when when you were talking earlier, and, you were talking about the need for schools, the the need for that. And so about... Probably about probably about two years ago, could even been as long as three years ago, I was, you know, in one of those hotels where, you know, it's the end of the night and you're... You still can't get to sleep and you're doing one of these. And, I was watching, a a major event that was a youth event, and it was out of California, they filled the stadium. It was incredible. And then at the end, they gave a charge. And then the charge, it was go out, prophesy in the streets, lay hands on people, you know, pray for healing, deliverance, all this out in the out in the streets. And so... And I'm sitting there, and I'm I'm I'm sitting there with expectation waiting for more, and the more never came, which was go to universities and be a witness and become doctors, lawyers, engineers. Go to the trades, become welders, become plumbers, become carpenters. There was there was there was nothing like that. So how are you gonna change the world, you know, with a bunch of people running around doing that and wanting to spend all their time dancing and laying on the floor and shaking? And and I don't I don't see how that can... That that is apostolic at all. And I think that that kind of thinking is really frustrating. The move of God, you know, within within cities and nations. That... And to me, that's a that's a very... It's a heavenly thinking, but it's not earthly. And so so what happens is, like, there's there's a there's a city that I decided I'm not going there anymore to preach because it has more bible schools than every... Than any city around. And you have all these people that are in my age group that never left the place because they're all waiting for this miracle to take place, and they're and they're functioning like that. Their children are backsliding because they did all that. They they they they ate that apple, and so they did all that. And so here they are, you know, they're in their sixties or seventies or whatever, and they've been working at McDonald's when they could own four or five of them. You know? And so I so I don't I don't see that model. You know? And it may be a revivalist model, but I... But even then, even with revival, none of us can do anything about it. Only... To me, it's a it's a god given thing. So so I think what you were saying, you know, having to do with preparation of the generations is so critical, and it's a critical function of the apostolic. And
this goes to the issue of, you know, again, if we use fivefold kind of thinking about it, we were lamenting that so much of it goes now by the... So would apostolics come back in a little bit? And... But we still had clarity on it. And we were saying like this, we we know of various well known organizations that use the term, but it really... What they mean is prophetic. And the problem is that the only tool that you got is a hammer, then everything looks like a nail. So everything they do is, like, prophetic, but they call it different things. Right? So one of the... Again, the discipline of thinking through the different lenses is very useful. So I get another... Yeah. I've been outed as someone who likes diagrams, and let me give you another one. So one of the ways to actually discipline ourselves in thinking through fivefold kind of dynamics is let's say you put the word church at the center here. Whatever we mean by that, and you might say, let's start with what we know. So let's say shepherd's view of the church. Shepherd, pastor, tell us, idealize what you think the church is. Give us your best... Kingdom comes... You know, the heaven comes to earth for the shepherd. What does it look like? Well, it's gonna look like a place of healing, restoration, love, relationships, forgiveness, flourishing human community. You got it really hot, really good. Right? It's a dynamic place. And, you know, anyone who's been in a community like that knows it's really powerful. If you took the teacher and asked the teacher, teacher, tell us what you think. Idealize it. Just go to town. Paint the picture of the church that you think, you know, we should have. Well, it's a place of learning where truth is loved, respected, integrated instruction. It's kind of like study depth, insight, articulation. Beautiful. Right? It's pretty amazing, and it wasn't a place you'd love to go to. Evangelist, you know, tell us what you think the best of church. You know? You know? Well, it's a place... It's a yes. You know? A place where god's salvation is experienced. Things are being restored to the, you know, to the original kind of intention that god had for it. Everything that evangelist points us towards. Right? Restoration, salvation, healing. It's a great place to belong to. Prophet, tell us your place. What's the church look like for a prophet? Well, it's gonna look like, you know, a good prefigurative community. It like... It's it's like how we should be living when god is king, when god is center, like you see in the, you know, in the coming of Jerusalem, you know, the heavenly Jerusalem comes down to earth where those things connect where, you know, everyone gathers around the throne, and it's this amazing kind of place. And, again, it's a wonderful place where justice faithfulness and holiness is rendered. And here we got the issue, the the apostle. So the apostle really is the nation impacting beyond the kingdom of god and its broader impact. And the question we ask ourselves is, which is the real church? Yeah. It's right over here, isn't it? It's kind of like... But we've we've kind of narrowed it down to perhaps that net and a little bit of that in the last forty years. But I think and the charismatic movement in the last while has also gone there. But I think this is the thing that's really we're getting clarity on now a bit more. And importantly, and that's for all the reason to go deeper.
You you... You'll take on that, John. Yeah. Well, one of the problems is the charismatic movement has turned into the charismatic movement. And you... One guy got it. Alright. But
I wanna go back to your... Oh, yeah. That one. So you gotta be too fast. So
going back to to, what you were what you were doing about the, the apostle And, so the process, let's say, of becoming, an apostle. It's one thing to be apostolic. It's another thing to be an apostle. And one of the reasons why I changed the name from apostles, you know, International Coalition of Apostles to Apostolic Leaders is an apostle should be a leader, and apostolic, in my mind, was referring to the missional purpose. They should they should have a missional purpose. And... So both goes to function. Right? So... Right. Right. And we had so many people called apostles that Yeah. Yeah. That were just legends in their own mind. You know? So, you know, God and Kelly had a clean house. So... But but... So going going back to... I think it's... Oh, yeah. I'm sorry. It's alright. Okay. Going back to what you were show... Showing earlier when we were here. So so here we have the apostle. You know? And, like, from from my own life, I didn't begin as an apostle. But I meet all these people, especially when I'm in the upper third and the lower third of the world, who say, well, I'm an apostle. And I said, well, how do you know you're an apostle? Well, I don't like people. So therefore, I'm an apostle. You know? Or or I'm an apostle. How do you know you're an apostle? Because prophet so and so, who we all know is a phenomenal prophet, laid hands on me and said I was. You know? And...
But to me, there's a promise...... Handing those things out at conferences a year... A couple of years ago. Yeah. Yeah. They were actually giving out apostolic
Yeah. Gift to... Yeah. That's inside. Some of them by people I knew. So... Tell me about it. But but, you know, I began as an evangelist. Prisons, jails, military bases, I led thousands of men to Christ, and maybe a couple 100 got... Actually got saved. And... Well, there is a difference. Yes. Yes. Yes. Is a difference. Yes. And and then I began to travel as a prophet, and words of wisdom, words of knowledge, I would call people out of the audience, you got a tumor, blah blah blah. And I... Or I'd have a prophetic word. And sometimes I was called a prophet because I was just plain arrogant. And and and then God did a terrible thing and called me to plant a church. I felt I thought he hated me. You know? Because when you're in these two roles, you're an expert on local church. But the moment you plant one, you discover, yes, you are a rebel. You know? And, really, you don't know half as much as what you think. And and now you're paying for your sins. Right? Yeah. Right. It's kinda like it's kinda like the the wind analogy that that Mark gave, you know, and you discover you're full of hot air. You know? So so so then so then I I enter into this pastoral role, and I couldn't wait to get over it. And I eventually took the church and divided it into three or four churches. I did it just before they threw me out. And so... And then I didn't know what to do when a couple of guys began to, you know, say I was an apostle. I had to I had to look up and research all that for over a year to figure out just what it what it meant. But but there's a process. And and when you you were... And you were you were sharing on also our identity, you know, and like you like you asked apostle Joe, about, you know, what's his strong gifts and that kind of thing. Could you could you expand more on that?
Yeah. So it's interesting that, we have language. And one of the tools that we use is called basing and phasing, in helping people understand this process that's been talked about here. Because even though in the case of, let's say, let's take Joe, for instance, if let's say he was... Oh, and let's say he came to church. Let me just draw another diagram. And, you know, we're using this idea of base and phase. And the idea is that you have a base gift, which would be your primary. And I think I would argue that from what I can determine, there's something of a calling. I like the word vocation or calling because Paul uses that twice, three times in Ephesians four. And I said the language indicates identity. So there's something deep about our primary identities using the... With Ephesians categories. So let's say one's a primary prophet. Then the other ones exist, you know, not in your not in your base, so your a p e s t. So you might say... I use s, by the way. I think it's a better translation than pastor, and pastor is so complicated for us. It's just... It's not a term that we can really use with clarity anymore. Shepherd. But shepherd is a better... Good shepherd kind of thing. So so the person might come to the church either by by conversion or by transfer. A church might then say, well, okay. Go and hang out with the school of... You know, maybe call it a school of prophets, but... And so there's a group of people over there that are learning how to do it together, and there's a kind of... They hold each other accountable. But there's a group of people who learn prophetic, and you can go and learn from them. So go and hang out with them. It could be two years, whatever whatever time it is. And then they might, at a certain time, determine, well, you got some issues with evangelists. Go and hang out with evangelists. Right? Because even if you might never be one yourself, you're gonna learn what they do, and you'll be trained in the way of an evangelist, which actually, by the way, has got a scriptural element to it, to do the work of an evangelist. You'll understand them. You hang out with them for a year, and you you come back to your base for a while. And then you might say, well, go and hang out with the shepherds. And you know what? You begin to work your way around. And this could take... Whoever cares. That doesn't really matter how long it could take. It take a lifetime, but we're going take ten years. You begin to kind of get better at all these ones too. So again, your own capacities are enhanced by actually learning what others do within the body. I need you to be me. And I think this is the thing about fivefold. It's not one, not two, not three. One of the great dangers if we just go... We we begin to think of it only in in terms of one. I think it's a problem. And and so we we need to realize that we do need each other. We're a body, and the body can't be divided against itself. I I I think the...
An apostle should be multi gift... Multi gifted, you know, at least in at least in three or four
of of the five... And and that's the mature version. Right? I mean, like, you would think a mature version. Yeah. That would be that would be that.
So so in in in looking at that, then there are certain gifts that we're stronger in. So we... So there is such a thing, would think, as a hyphenated apostle. And what I mean by that is that your stronger gift could be profit, but you could also... Because of your... You have an apostolic unction, that could be your secondary. Yeah. So, actually, the the apostolic does not always have to be primary. You know? It's it's like I would consider yourself and and others, you know, like, you know, what I would call apostolic teachers. And so so there's... Those are the two strong gifts. It's too strong. Not that you don't have Yeah. Two two more. Yeah. And and so... But we also can reverse that and say, teacher apostle, or we could say evangelist apostle. Yes. And we probably need more evangelists.
I would say for the missional church movement, which I've been part of, you know, for the last twenty or so years, I think we're missing the evangelists. The good the people who sing the song and get others to buy in on the organization, think they're still hanging out in church growth. Right. Where they are the heroes. Right? Mhmm. And I would say, like, for anyone who think about the the power of integration of these various gifts, you think about the last forty, fifty years, which we call it, you know, the era of church growth. It's really been the reintegration of the evangelistic function back into the church. And of course, the church grew. They didn't know what to do with everyone, so they grew the church into very large kind of that's a relatively new phenomenon. But, you know, if it was an apostolic version, there would be lots of church plants because church planting would be the it's the primary apostolic kind of function. So the you know, but they've been hanging out in church growth for a time and, you know, so they're not hanging out the rest of us. Yeah. Because it says all are called to the work of the evangelist, but we have this thing,
like, do as you're led. Yeah. And if I was gonna do as I was led right now, I'd be on Michael Moore's white couch. You know? So so so, basically, you know, one of the things we need are equipping evangelists. And, you know, with me, you know, I can't say I do much group evangelism anymore because of the nature of minister... I'm speaking to ministers. I'm speaking to leaders, business or otherwise. And... Or I'm speaking in a congregational conference meeting where, basically, they're all saved anyway. So it's almost like a... You can convict them of sin, but... So... But but the thing is with with with that, so I find Starbucks to be my mission field Right. Because I think we all still need to witness. So so that's... That... And to me, that that is the biggest missing gift in the apostolic movement is is is the ministry of the evangelist.
I tend to agree too. And also, an evangelist with more than just platform skills, which Right. Or or the or the or the guerrilla evangelist on the street, which was very two distinct models in in in America. But there ought to be other versions of it as well. You know? More subtle, maybe, presence evangelists as well in relational... Relational forms as well as the proclamatory versions. Now now I wanna get to get to some little,
you know, going from hamburger to steak now. I wanna I wanna I wanna go to the five q. Can you give us a little more?
Alright. Right. He's turned this into an interview with me, which I thought I'd really had, but... Because I'd... I'm more interested in what he's on about. But I will answer this simply this way, is that five q... I've done four books on the fivefold ministry now. This is like been an obsession. It came up in my first book called The Shaping of Things to Come, and it has been a long term obsession. And here's what I have learned, John, is that if you love something long enough, it will reveal itself to you. Two fingers. Two. It's great, isn't it? So if if you love something long enough, it will reveal itself to you. And I think I've loved this this topic a long, long time. So I began to be interested in this idea of using it as assessments for organization function, dysfunction. And I thought I'd write a kind of 8,000 word. I never thought I could... You know, I don't write 8,000 word documents. Right? But I thought I'd do it this time, and I was gonna give it away free with an assessment called five q diagnostic. And that was... That's all I intended until I realized, you know, I began to do research for it. And I, in the permanent revolution, had a... It's just a page on it that these these fivefold capacities are actually part of the creation order, not just the redemption order. That is you can see them outside the churches, which I think what we were saying before. There are people outside the church who are naturally entrepreneurial, who like pioneering or structuring or design. There are people outside the church who are naturally spiritual or have that prophetic functionality, which in a broader sense, you know, is calling us to faithfulness, repentance, all that stuff. I I think of it as much as we might find them irritating. I think that the environmentalist movement is a secular prophetic movement. They're saying if you reap the wind, you will sow... Reap the wind, you will sow the whirlwind. Right? Sow to the wind, you reap the whirlwind. Well, that's kind of what's happening now. But we'll shut our ears and rush at them. Classic. Are are there people outside of the church that are equivalent to evangelists? You betcha. Everyone with an Apple Mac is an evangelist. Right? They call them brand evangelists. Right? Because it's good news. Right? And there's old temple there. There's old people you can go and pay. They give you pastoral attention. All that stuff is fantastic. And every... Everything sinks. You can never leave. Try and leave it. Your life will fall apart. It's like predestination. Yeah. So... Anyway, are there are there people outside the church who correspond... Do you have to be a Christian to care for people? No. And then are there people outside the church that teach? No brainer. So these all exist outside the church. But I never really substantiated it. Right? So I decided I'd I'd try and do that. So here's where we go again. And this is where it got really big on me. Everything builds around Jesus, as I said. I think I put him right at the center because all the information about who we are to be is is contained there. So I began to look outside. Where did Jesus get these things from? If he didn't invent them, atheist. And by the way, the language of apeist is all secular language. Apostela was a secular function. All of them were. Prophet was poet, and they had prophets, you know, fortune tellers. All of them were there. And so it hints that the functions are beyond the church. I began to look at things called archetypes. Archetypes are recurring patterns in history. It's like recurring, you can see patterns of history. Patterns in culture is a little more harder to see. But the ones we all know of is the usual disk, for instance. But Myers Briggs is classic archetypal. It's built on archetype. So what an archetype is a pattern. Why does INTP work for me every time? It it really does nail me. Why? Because it's a pattern. Some of you are that as well. And we are. It's a pattern. You just got to pay attention to it. Will be ADD enough to see what's happening. And then your so your archetypes heroic forms of people we build statues to, our myths and our stories are heroes. What do they tell us about ourselves, etcetera? And I thought, wow, that's pretty amazing out there. If you use the categories, they're all there. Yeah. I mean, really. And then I began to look, well, where do they come from? Well, the only way you answer that is they have to come from the creator God. Therefore, they're grounded somehow rooted in what we call theology. So you can... You look at the doctrine of God. The roots of apes today, God... Apostle is sentness. Sentness is, you know, Jesus is eternally sent to... This is the big discovery of of the last hundred years or so. We call that that god is a missionary god. Sentence is is who god is. It's not what he does. It's it's part of his nature. Prophetic is a holiness and justice relationship. Won't let you deal with him as a thing. No idolatry. All that stuff go deep within the prophetic function. Covenant. Evangelist. Well, God is good news. I mean, he's a savior. Always has been a savior, redeemer from the foundation of the world. Good news. Shepherd, social Trinitarianism, all that stuff about God. You know, love invites us into his family, you know, adopting us. Teacher, his truth, you know, omniscient. So you can actually say that it it... Apeis is grounded in God. Now that got a little bit bigger now. Woah. So grounded in God, laced throughout creation. So you got two there. Perfectly embodied, we call it reconstituted or recapitulated in Jesus Christ. And here's where it gets interesting. Before it gets to you and me over here, it goes into the body of Christ. Right. And this is where, like, the whole five q thing became interesting to me. Because we're only an expressionist already latent in the body. So, you know, so that that the body, the name hints at it, has got all the functions in it. And so you can look at this at at at your... At the body before you even get to individual expression. It... It's functions of ecclesia. It's functions of the body of Christ. And that's now getting really interesting. And then you're in... You and I are over here at the far end of a process that began in God. Now five q really is about quotient or capacity that actually builds on this system here. So it's not just... It's a it's a key to interpreting scripture even. So I thought I was going a little mad. Thought it's too too big. But, actually, I think it stands. And it's not the only way you can... Not the only key to scripture, but darn, does it deliver a lot of insight. So that's the five q thing. You asked it. I'm the lord of the long answer, brother. You know? Like, I
don't know how to answer short answers. That's alright. I like being taught. Yeah. You know? That's it. We we can never stop learning.
Never stop learning. You know the sign of the the baptism of the spirit for me? Uh-huh. Unquenchable fire in my brain. I just when I got... Tongues came later, to be honest, but just a burning need. And I thought I never thought a clear thought until that moment in my life when I was 23. And it's just like I have... It hasn't stopped ever since. And I still see it as, like, one of the signs, you know. Yeah. I was I was 29 about three, four weeks from
turning 30. Broke a door of a church down 03:00 in the morning. Me and another guy, we were stone drunk, talking one another into getting saved. Got saved, delivered, set free, filled the holy ghost, and I I had no feelings. And I I came out of there crying my eyes out and gave me a heart, and I just have had the passion ever since. I have trouble going to bed at night because I'm thinking too much, and I can't... I'm excited about waking up because... Mean you still have trouble? Yeah. I still have trouble. Yeah. Yeah. I'm about a four, five hour night sleeper because I'm... I just I just... So excited about getting up. Wow. You know? It's like, we're gonna accomplish something today. Yeah. Put that into your kind of... Into your doctrinal creed. Yeah. It doesn't kinda fit in easier. Had a boxing coach when I was fifth... Grade. And he said, you know what you do when you get knocked down? So what? Get up quick. He said, you know what you do when you get hurt? So what? So keep on fighting. You know? And and, know, those kind of credos are built into you. But looking at this, Jesus, in my mind, took out of the secular, you know, more than he took out of the the religious realm. That's why, you know, he he was he was really a revolutionary. He he wasn't out to establish a religion at all. He was... In my mind. Okay? And correct me if I'm wrong. And and in that, he he used these very secular words. And, not not only not only words like apostle, totally secular word. And, I mean, to the Jews, I mean, that was a terrible word and, and to others as well. And then for for what it meant. And, because generals, when they were put into retirement and given a territory, they also were given the title apostolos. So... But the other thing was that the word occupy. Occupied to become a military word, having to do with an aggressive force that has won and taken over, and now they're now they're governing this. And then, of course, the word ecclesia, another really offensive word, you know, having to do with government, having to do with penetration of of culture, of society. And and then when you look at, when I look at the parables, oh my gosh. I mean, it's all secular. He uses... He's not he's not going back to the Old Testament and use an Old Testament scripture to prove text anything. He's basically just... He's telling these secular stories that relate to their culture. It's very contextualized to what... Where they are. And so so I I see all of this coming out of... Very clearly, and I I think very clearly in what you're saying here. Yeah. It's interesting.
You know, Again, to get here again... And I believe that, as I already said, I think Jesus being the absolute center for the church. And we cannot afford to ever lose sight of of that center without actually losing ourselves. Our identity is bound in with Jesus. Right? But there's a whole theory, again, I'm apology for my geekiness, but there's a strong tea in me, is that there's a thing called recapitulation theory, which derives from Paul's use of a language in a couple of three or so texts in Colossians and Ephesians where Jesus sums up the entire... Re summarizes our world. In other words, he reconstitutes it. And so if you look at Jesus, and Paul uses the term as the second Adam, he takes all the brokenness of the world, which is actually, you know, this was God's intent. He creates the world and it shatters. So this is broken. They're still there. These patterns and archetypes are still there, but they're broken. And what Jesus does is he takes them, and not just apiates, but all of humanity, and he relives a perfect life. And it's called recapitulation theory. Irenaeus was very, is the theologian mostly known as this goes back to the third century, but also to Paul. And Jesus perfectly relives it. So what I would say simply is that if we find the best of humanity, that Jesus is not just for Christians to follow. He actually is the perfect human being. He's the second Adam that I was the new humanities constituted there that we all pattern off this person. And I would ever say that whatever we use about changing culture, changing things, it's always gotta look more like Jesus. One of my great concerns today personally is that the church... Yeah. I'm gonna just say it. It just doesn't look a lot or sound a lot or doesn't act a lot like Jesus. You know? And I think this is this is the most concerning thing at all. Because if we get that wrong and we get all excited about, you know, a non Jesus kind of religion, it gets very dangerous. And Bonhoeffer talked about Christless Christianity. So how do we ensure that we're not Christless Christians? Well, discipleship and modeling ourselves on Jesus. And that looks like something. It's not a guesswork. Right? Most of us don't study the gospels very much, but we actually got the gospels there to guide us as to what it means to be a Christ like person. Well, we look at Jesus. But when we get into the Christianity and that doesn't look like Jesus, it's abomination. And we should be repenting that we... After two thousand years of of the gospel, two thousand years of of the bible, two thousand years of, know, church and spirituality and theology, we still don't look like Jesus. It's it's it's not good enough. And we have to really come back to that one. I think that has got to be the most important thing that we can ever kinda... Personally, I think that's just the most important. Especially when we're talking about transforming the world, we need to make sure it's in the in the pattern and the way of Jesus. That's where we have to be careful about being so called relevant
or contextualization. And contextualization could be a good word and a bad word. I mean, we can overdo it. Yeah. And so we have to we have to be careful in those things because we're... When we... Sometimes when we're when we're in that, we're actually getting farther away. We're trying to be so relevant that we're irreverent. Yeah. And and we're and we're really we're really not... How can I put it? We're we're not coming from a kingdom orientation, you know, that... Of king Jesus. Could
Yeah. Yes, sir. The kingdom of God. Right? I mean, we got whole theologies built on, you know, on, you know, taking taking the... Again, the gospels out of the equation, building merely on atonement theories. Again, I'm I'm all for every form of atonement God wants to give. I'm for it. Right? I don't have to question that. But, I mean, you can't just simply here's an insight that I've learned over the last few years. And it relates to APES because we've reduced it. But if I may, another diagram. Sorry, guys. This has been very deeply personal, and it probably has dawned on me in the last five to seven years. So I've had a lot of time to think about it, but I think it's true. Let's see what you think. I think if you can see this as like total truth, if you can. If online, it's universal truth. Everything there. When the bible uses the word heretic, generally, what it means as opposed to what it's come to mean in our language, a heretic is is not someone who's bad or wrong. The heretic is someone who's taken a piece of what was previously undiscovered. So the heretic had discovered something that others have overlooked or rediscover something that had been lost. That's good because it's something to be celebrated there. What the problem of the heretic is that that becomes the primary focus of what they're attending, and they forget that they lose focus on it belongs to something total that's much bigger. They become radicalized and fanaticized. And here's the deal. Protestants are so good at this. Right? So we keep on going down. We define ourselves over against others. How many Baptist churches we got? How many, you know, Pentecostal denominations do we have? How many different theories of... And everyone argues that theirs is the only way. So every heretics got a verse of scripture or two or three because they've just analyzed it to death and they compare themselves against everyone else. And the only way... So the problem is all our problems come from going down like that, just further further down. And I think what we've got to do is go up. It's the only way we we have to have a bigger picture to make sense of our smaller pictures and to realize that truth is always bigger than who we are. If you think you've got truth nailed down, it's not truth. If you think you got God in your pocket, it ain't God. I hate to tell you this, but it's not God. It can't be contained in a doctrine. A doctrine is like a sacrament. It only points you towards that which it's pointing you towards. It cannot contain it, and we get stuck on, you know, doctrine. You've got 25,000 denominations, you know, in the world. Everyone thinks they got, you know, the bastion of truth and beauty. Right? Whereas in actual fact, we're to think much bigger about ourselves. Well, based on that definition,
we have a lot of heretics within within the apostolic camp as well Yeah. Or the or the so called apostolic camp. Could... Can you do your two finger trick? Yeah. Two... Yeah. There you go. Okay. So some... One of the one of the problems that that I see within... Especially within the so called charismatic apostolic camp, the the n... The NAR kind of thing, is they see this as that, well, we are on the prophetic edge. And I would say that that's much more of the pathetic edge rather than the prophetic edge because in order to be here on that, you cannot... You have to be the sum total of all truth that's going on before you, of all revealed truth. Acts three, Jesus is in heaven waiting for all things to be... You know, that the prophets have said to be restored. So in other words, how can you be here if you're not evangelical? How can you be here if you're if you're... If if if you're not fundamental? How can you be here, you know, if if you're not reformed? How can how can you be here if you're not charismatic or Pentecostal? In other words, you know, or or Wesleyan or or or everything. I was on a plane one time. When I'm on a plane, I don't like to... I just like to talk to the Me. To the attendants. You know? Me too. Don't do this. Yeah. It's my quiet time. You know, my alone time. And so, usually, you know, I'm flying in first class and and I have somebody use... Used to be a business person, now it's a tourist or something, but used to be a business person. And the first thing they'd like to do is, like, well, you're going you're going to work or going home? And, know, you you tell them. And they say, what do you do? So my answer was always, I'm a Pentecostal minister. Because the moment I said that, they'd go, oh, well, I got a lot of work to do. I'm kinda tired. You know? You know? So so they'd leave me alone because they figured I'm the nut job on the plane. You know? So Don't stir him up. No. Don't... Yeah. Don't... They don't wanna get me started. See? So so I'm on a plane one time several... Many years ago, and a guy does the whole routine with me. And I said, well, I'm a Pentecostal minister. And he goes, what's that? I'm like, oh, man. Now I'm in a discussion. And so so I said to him, well, I'm an evangelical like like like, Billy Graham. He went, oh. And then I said, but I'm a fundamentalist like Jerry Fall when he went, oh. You know? And then I said, and then I'm I'm a Pentecostal like Oral Roberts. And he went, you know, I'm kinda tired and I got a lot of work to do. That was that was the end of that. But the truth is, in order to be here, you gotta be a Baptist, a Methodist, a Presbyterian, an Anglican. Yeah. I mean Yes. Because all of them started with a restored truth, but but the but the following group that came up, they classified them as heretics. So reductionism
is the problem. Right? Yeah. Reduce truth down to something formulaic. Right. And then we we ask people to kinda buy in on that narrow truth. Mhmm. And there ain't nothing wrong with celebrating a recovered truth. Right. Just remember, you haven't got it all boxed up. So have some humility and and and and some wonder and awe and things that help us look up and think we haven't got it all together and, you know, it's really... The whole fivefold thing has been reduced down to twofold or onefold. I think it's largely onefold in the evangelical world. They don't really do shepherding that well. I hate to tell you this is not they do teaching really well. It's the one thing we've done well. It's a little heady, but it's pretty good. But everything else is not done well at all.
Totally agree. Totally
agree. And in the Pentecostal world, it's prophetic largely. Right. Shepherding. Mhmm. And then the teacher is right down the bottom end, so that, you know, they, you know, lack an understanding of things. You know? Well, even even the shepherding many times
is not the kind of shepherding that's pastoral care. Right. It's shepherding by control and authority. You know? So it's just misuse of that term. And that had... By the way, the brothers that led the shepherding movement, if you ever listen to their teachings, I don't think any of them... I've never heard any of them say anything that was off. You know? But it was but it was followers that that really messed up that had that had wrong hearts. You know? And so we have to be careful because we have to realize that all of these different moves started with a revealed truth. Mhmm. A revelation of of a revealed truth and restoration of of either a revelation or a doctrine back into the church. So that's that's good. Now where do where do you see the apis going? That's a broad question, I realize. Very broad. Well,
I think, actually, as I think I said before in the last session, I think this is really opening a lot of doors. If we take it away from a classically Pentecostal charismatic conversation, give it theological weight. And by the way, why I speak like this too partly in using theology? You're really giving what you're saying authority in the sense that where as it draws from scripture, it's got resonance. Right? Mhmm. It's the love language of the church. If you really wanna motivate god's people... I mean, corporate American language is fine. You know? It's good. You know? But if you really wanna get to the code, you gotta use good biblical language, which actually commits us to being theologically astute. If nothing else, it's to change, you know, to speak within the love language of, you know, of the church. So what we're seeing now is if you can broaden out the conversation and put it in terms of functions, mean, it's so the whole APS conversation is exceedingly fruitful at the moment. My concern is that we just don't blow it up because I think it is an opportunity for us to heal ourselves. As I said, like we go up to heal. I think what we're doing now is reducing we're healing the reduction of ministry into twofold by integrating APE back into the equation. And it's very promising because in a, you got the missional function p, you got the incarnational function, the commitment to going deep and paying attention and being loyal. Those two are very foundations for the church because they set up... You know, it's it's a very strong missionary function. Evangelists, I think, you know, we need more people who can speak within the within the language and within the cultural code of the prevailing... The emerging generations. And I think we need to have more sophistication on that because, you know, methodology that was derived completely different circumstances no longer works for us. And I think it alienates people. So we need better evangelists to teach us how to communicate now.
Think The good news people. I think some things have been really taken a little too far. And I think I can get away with saying this because my basic theological construct is phenomenology is charismatic and then probably reform. And... But yet I'm not a dominionist. I'm not into the theocratic reign of of cities, nations. I I believe that theocratic reign is over you and I, our family, the church, and everything else is by influence. But yet some within within the apostolic camp have made those pronouncements, you know, about about dominionism. And, and I believe there will be dominion with the return of Christ, absolute dominion. So... And I feel that that theology is really really a critical issue with with the apostolic movement Mhmm. And and and serious study Mhmm. And and prayer and and also centered on Christ. You know? I'll never forget one of the greatest books I think I ever read. It's about that thick. It took me forever to read. It was Erdesham's book
on On Jesus. On, you know, the centrality of Christ. On... Yeah. It was amazing. Yeah. Just with the theocracy, you know, what's been mentioned here is there's been moves afoot to... You know, that that somehow the church is gonna be over... You know, assuming that the church fully represented Jesus would rule over the nations and all. And much of our theology actually is, you know, the whole Christendom construct that the church, you know, is a special deal. But the interesting thing is that I would simply say again, going to Jesus on this, is that if in the bible, you know, if Yahweh, in the Old Testament, god, Yahweh is... Rules over all, he claims absolute loyalty and you have to renounce your idols, no more idols. You have to give loyalty to the one god. That in Christ, we know that actually offer worship to God through this person, Jesus, who then in turn offers worship to the father. In one Corinthians, he has this Jesus is worshiping. If worships in offering offering my world back to God, Jesus takes all that which is offered to him, put under his feet, and he offers it to the father in this ultimate beautiful act where he worships the father. And he models worship for us. There is submission to the father. But we have to render our obedience to this person, which changes everything. Everything. Mhmm. Because once you put the name Jesus in front of lord... You know, if I said John is lord, I think it's pretty cool. Think. And we've only just met. I like taking over. But, you know, there's some dark spots. Right? You you'd admit that. Right? Yeah. Totally. If I said Hitler is Lord, that's not good for me. I'm Jewish, so that's kinda my money here. Right? But if I said Jesus, Lord, the name I use in the front of that changes absolutely everything. Because I look at Jesus, and I know what God is like. Mhmm. So this changes everything. So I'm alright with the word Christocracy, if we go, but that is very different. Than theocracy. Yeah. And it's not about world domination. It's world transformation. And he... The gospel transforms societies. We don't dominate. And unfortunately, we become... If we don't get our notions of power right, we we we become dominators. That's two write downs, Christocracy
versus theocracy and and the other one is transform.
Transformation, not domination. Not denomination.
Yeah. Yeah. And I think the heart of man is to dominate. Yeah. And and and also the heart of fearful man is to escape. So we have these two extremes. We have the escapist, you know, before things get really bad, we're gonna fly fly away. And and then we have, you know, over here, you know, we're we're gonna take we're gonna take dominion prior to the return of Christ.
You know? So You know, just this is totally off, but it's kind of related. You know, when you say like fight and flight, you know Yeah. Is the two responses. There's meant to be two others that Fight go with and flight. Right. There's... Those two... There's the other one is fake it, freeze, or fake it. So like if some... Like animals are... Like, they either fake being dead or... You know? Right. So you think about that and put that in fake it Uh-huh. Or freeze. You know?
You know? We we got a lot like that too. Yeah. We do. We got a lot of fake and faking. Yeah. That'll preach.
Fight, flight, fake, freeze.
Mhmm. Yeah. Now we're getting, you know,
so good. Late in the afternoon. It's late in the afternoon. How much longer do we go? As long as our kidneys people are thinking, oh my goodness. When are they gonna see as long as our kidneys can handle it. That's right. We had our preemptive coming through here on that one. So one one one one one other thing.
We... In Revelations chapter one verse six that we're a holy nation, which we are a holy nation of kings and priests unto God be his glory forever and ever. Amen. And it doesn't say that this group over here is priests and this group over here is kings, but it's using it as a metaphor. And and, basically, it's talking about having a priestly role and a kingly role, but that can be taken to an extreme too. That can that can become very problematic. I was in a church where... Several years ago, and and his church was gonna be all kings, so he called it king's church. You know? And he was only gonna have kings in the church. And and I said How did that work out for him? I said I said to him, you know, and he he got... He he he didn't like me. You know? He didn't like me. And... Because I said to him, I said, all you're gonna have is a bunch of elitists who eventually are gonna throw you out. And guess what? Guess what happened? And the Churchilling group, of course, only to us. It grew real big at first and then went, you know, went down. And so I think we have to be really careful in how we use that terminology.
Agree. You know? And Yeah. So it was a problem. I mean, like, I think the idea of prophet, priest, and king is really good for our Christology. In other words, you look at Jesus, I think it makes a lot of sense. Mhmm. I think APES carries more code because it's got the apostolic, the percentile, the missionary function, which is so deeply important in the deal and and what else? The evangelist is there too. But... And I think it's definitely biblical language is much clearer on that. But I think it's really problematic when you apply it to believers. Mhmm. It always dies in... And the circles uses it. It dies the death of a thousand qualifications. Mhmm. So the very people I'm working with now used to use that language. When they use the word prophet... I mean, not what we mean by prophet. Not at all. Right? It's preaching. Right. I think, no. But preaching can be prophetic, but it's not always. You can't reduce it down to preaching and make sense of the bible. You know? Correct. Or, you know, king. What do we mean we're all kings? Well, yeah, that got... You know, Jesus has some things to say about that. So I don't know. It's just... It's useful, but I just... You know, it's better than the twofold. Yeah.
Well, then with then with with that, that whole thing on on priests and kings, the... We have to be, I think, extremely careful on that on on that. Right. But that that also takes us into some some other areas as well. And I think that some of these things, when they first get revealed, they get overdone. You know?
Yep. It's it's it's a classic thing. Discovered something has been missing for a while and you get overexcited about it. Right.
Yeah. Right. Okay. How about... Do any of you have any questions that you'd like bring us to your comments? Gonna hickle us if you will. Yeah. And if you don't, just make up a couple. You can hickle John any time. Yes.
Mark. Thank you for twenty some years of faithful work. It's been a great blessing. And what are you reading lately, studying lately? You're like the mad scientist in the room. So I'm wondering what is what is what is captured you? What are what are what are the things that you're reading, people you're reading, rabbit trails you're going down that are that are sort of the new the new things you're working on? And please repeat that for the stream. Oh, okay. What am I reading? I think that's a summary.
So, yeah, the idea of it, you know, Mark was asking me the question. So what, you know, what have I been reading lately? It's interesting. My last six, seven years have been... My prayer life has just gone off the wall. I mean, it's just... I can spend whole days now in prayer. And I've always struggled with it. I have to confess. It's never been I've been particularly good at. And... But, you know, along with that has become... I'm gonna confuse... I ended up reading this dude, and you're gonna laugh at just the name, but his name is Hans Urs von Baltazar. He's a he's a Catholic theologian. Oh my goodness. I mean, I've fallen in love. I mean, he is incredible. I've never read anyone who's loved the scriptures like that. I mean, we've often caricature Catholics as not loving scripture. I'm telling you, I've studied a lot of scripture, I've read most Protestant theologians. No one has done it. This guy. So I'm reasonably obsessed with the. And and for some reason, my prayer, you know, my prayer life is attached to that, coming to know god in a bigger way. But, you know, and... Yeah. I I I think that he'd be very important in it. In terms of leadership and design thinking has been interesting for me. The idea of how you can design organizations for certain outcomes, that's been quite intriguing. Yes. I think that's the kind of thing. It sounds all geeky and all that, but for me, it's been the rich resource. And then whatever else I need to do for leadership, I will just dig it out as I need it. But nothing captured. Can I ask him what he's reading and what's capturing your attention?
Well, read your book pretty thorough and just finished up a book called The Secular City. I'm trying to think of his name, Harvey Cox. Alright. That was around in the sixties. Yeah? Yeah. Around in the sixties. And this is kind of a rewrite of it. Oh, right. Yeah. And You know, he became Pentecostal
later on. You know It's the start of the death of God kind of theology. Doctor
Cottle said that in the rewrite, you can you can see that because the secular city now is a lot different than the original one he wrote. Yeah. And by the way, Harvey Cox is the head of theology at Harvard. You know? So so that's that's a book that Right. I just I just finished. How interesting. He just did the future of faith,
which is I think very apparent next step for us to discuss
in the apostolic Right. How interesting. And he said very good things about the Pentecostal and all. He had this encounter with the Holy Spirit. Right? Yeah. Because he was like the guy who, like, one of the founding theologians of what became known as the death of God theology Mhmm. In the sixties. And then he, you know, he fundamentally has this experience which shifts him radically.
I think this guy went from reformed theology to death of God, and then he went into liberation theology as well. And talk about a
turn. But you actually think about it again as how the things are healed is by going up. You'll find roots of... Is our liberator. Oh my goodness. Thank God for that. And anyone who's been in oppressive. This is an interesting thing. This is for for global, you know, for global witness. This is interesting. You know, what I'm learning, Mark, one of the things is that, you know, in terms of our gospel messaging, we have very narrowed messaging appealing to a certain aspect of the human being. So on the one hand, in the West, apparently, and I think this is true, that western cultures are interested in truth or untruth. Innocence or guilt has been, you know, in our philosophy and, you know, interesting. We... We're more interested in those kind of ideas, more kind of more heady. The East is more interested in... Well, the issues they deal with is shame and honor, grace and disgrace. And if... You know, very different register of the human soul. And in fact, it's very hard for Westerners to truly understand narrative. And actually the bible's written largely in that, although it does deal with a lot of things that are true and untrue. Overwhelmingly, it's more about honor and shame and how, you know... And shame is an internal register, by the way. It's something you feel a way... Guilty is something where you're objectively guilty. Truth is something outside of ourselves. The the West, and this will come to what I'm saying about liberation. The the the South, the global South in both in South America and Africa is interested in power and the powerlessness, fear, or the absence of fear, fearlessness. So the idea, how can I be free from my fear? If you go into Africa, you've done much of, much of what African culture is is collective and very easily dominated by leaders who dominate them. Right. And then, you know, basically abuse or slavery or the things like that. It's interesting that each of these require a different register of the gospel. And the gospel deals with all of them. But what we're discovering now more and more is that in the West, we have... We're having to deal with more of these registers. I'll give you one example of it in terms of shame and honor. In America, it's very competitive. You've noticed. Right? Very competitive culture. The things about competition is that, you you get one winner, right? And it creates the loser, loser, loser. And that's like the internal register which costs you to cast your head down. Right? You create one idea of beauty. Someone's beautiful. Every one of us is ugly by comparison. Right? That's again... It's a... Now the thing is you can't deal with that with with with the traditional way of dealing... Sharing the gospel is you need forgiveness for your sins. Shame can't be dealt with by forgiveness for sins because you haven't sinned. But it is about God's unconditional love and his grace, and you have to major on that. And that God brings down the proud and raises up the downhearted. You know, that's a very different way of articulating the gospel, and we're gonna have to learn in our evangelism to be able to articulate more broadly. And for... If you look at the... You know, this issue down here, power powerlessness, I think the only way you make sense of Black Lives Matter is that you have a people who've been appropriated to slavery, and it's... They feel powerless. You know, they don't feel they have any power over their own fate. And we have to find dimensions of the gospel that really genuinely deal with this. You know? Otherwise, you have whole populations unhealed, you know Mhmm. And unredeemed for what they're dealing with. Anyway, it's just an interesting thing.
But you have to you have to contextualize all that when you go into those environments. And, you know, and I think many times when we go into those environments,
we go in strictly from the western. Yes. That's exactly right. So we have a reduced understanding of the gospel, and we misappropriate it. Correct. Yeah.
And so when you... Because somehow giving honor... Because we're so into, you know, this egalitarian thing, you know, that giving giving honor is somehow putting me in a subjective role or or, it's it's... It... You know, it's it's just not right, and we have all these attitudes. But you're not gonna get anywhere until you give honor. Know, you know, and and because they wanna honor you, they're not gonna receive from you unless they do. And same thing when you go into Africa. You gotta go in with power. You know, you get up in front you get up in front of a bunch of Africans and you start saying, well, you know, I just wanna share a word with you today. And, you know, I wanna tell you a story, and they're just gonna look at you like... I mean, the whole crowd is just now going to sleep, like half of this crowd is now. But but but but you you you have to approach them
with certain elements from their culture. Yeah. And that's why, like, often the African church deals a lot with powers, principalities because, of course, it's a power issue Right. And enslavement. So that's the issue that they... And they can teach us this. Yeah. Like, you teach... You go into an African conference
and you go into a Latin American conference, you go into any of this, you're not going in there as a teacher. You gotta go in there as a preacher. Yeah. But now when you have a group of ministers together, now you can be the teacher. Yeah. Interesting. Yep. Any other questions, Ron? Doctor Ron Kyle?
In your in your book, Permanent Revolution, you you give an example of the founder of the Visa Corporation.
Yeah.
In talking about the theology without borders, borders, how would you... Would you you talk about that a little bit? Well,
so... Yeah. I think... Let me just try to remember what we said about him there. I often use, like... His name is D Hawk, and he's an interesting dude. I mean, no one probably knows his name, yet he started Visa Corporation. Visa as in the credit card Visa. And I... He he wrote this incredible book after he retired. Strangely enough, he went into Buddhist retreat for ten years, came out and wrote this. Very spiritual. By the way, I think it's all creational order. It's very, very clever. It's very good. And but I'm saying it's paying attention to human beings here. And it's how you organize. And I would say for movements, it's really important that we learn how to organize through networking is what we were talking about too. Rather than having centralized structures of control, you you need to find other ways to motivate and maintain organization. So he comes up with this beautiful word called chaotic. He was approached by the credit cards. I remember credit cards, my folks had them. You know, in the sixties when it first came out, the idea was that you'd... Every organization had their own credit card. So going shopping is you'd... You had this whole concertina thing you some of us remember. You had to find the credit card appropriate to the organization. It was a pain, and it was never going to work. So the banks got him in to say, well, it's just chaos, not going to work. Banks like a lot of orders. So he had to try and find a way to make it work. And he came up with this idea. You've got to strike a balance between chaos and order. And he said, purpose and principle clearly defined, commonly understood, adhered to by those inside. You can do away with command and control because people act as... Because it's meaningful for them to act. So... But you've got to strike this balance. Right? So he comes up with purpose and principles. So these common ideas, and this is good for movement thinking that you you name them. I'll give you example, one or two of mine. And that people buy in on these very deeply in order to train deeply and you require conformity around core ideas, but you allow them to interpret it radically differently in their own. And by the way, he starts off he comes into an you know, a group of people like this, he shows a credit card and he says, anyone seen this Visa? Right? You've probably got one in your pocket, but you've all seen it's probably one of the biggest known brands in the world. It says, Anyone know where the headquarters of Visa is? And everyone goes, I don't know where the headquarters is. No? Don't know where the headquarters is. Anyone know where you can buy stocks and shares in Visa? Look around. No, no, there's no... You can't buy stocks and shares. He said, anyone know anything about Visa Corporation? At the time, it was a $1,200,000,000,000 a year... Trillion dollars a year going through that company. And had 500 employees in our headquarters. Now folks, that isn't bad. I think we can learn from that, right? And the idea is like it's this kind of principle at the core that you could then get adherence to. So I'd say that movements are DNA based organizations. They're adhering DNA ideas. And you... But you give people the right to kind of interpret it radically in different settings. So you get a lot of creativity going down. So I think that's I think that's what you were Yeah. Referring to. A good example of that was Paul.
He he spent...
Can I give you other? He spent about... Because it'd be worth...
A good example of that was was Paul, especially on his first missionary journey. He spent four months in each of the cities, the four cities of Galatia, and, then went away, for a year or two or three and then came back. And what he did was... What you said this morning, he planted the gospel, and then he allowed them to have time to incarnate it and express it in their own cultural, social terms. And then he... And as as I believe you said before, the ecclesia in Galatia was was not like the Ekklesia in Ephesus and so on and so on. So I I think maybe this is a a great word for us to at least consider for our step into the nations, not to carry so much cultural baggage with us. We need to find... I... I've changed chaotic because I don't like the word chaos to or that or adaptable. And I teach that or adaptable. So you got an order, a concord a concord at the at the center to which people can, on their own terms, commit completely, like like this apostolic revelation that we are into right now. And... But then adaptable. Let let them adapt it to their own culture and their own social mores and not tell them, you know, too much about what's right and what's wrong. I'll look to that. Yeah. I think that's the next frontier. I really do. A book, Theology Without Borders,
I've been reading recently. You probably... One of the one of the temptations in having these coalitions, these national coalitions, and I'm always asked about this. Well, do you have a manual? I said, no. Well, you need to have a manual and write down all the principles and how a coalition should function. The moment you do that, you've destroyed the chaotic. It's no it's no longer adaptable to the culture because every country is different. And what's a great problem in this country is not a great problem in this country. And so the coalition has to have the freedom. Like, there's not one coalition. And all the coalitions, national coalitions that are related to all of us, There's not one coalition that's like this coalition. But that could be true of the Nigerian coalition also. There's no other coalition like like the Nigerian coalition. And and once you start cookie cutting and then you start destroying the movement, now what you have is is this organization. Now you got to put in control. You have to have a governmental system. You have to have all of that. And all that does is slow down the process. That works fine in a local church. You know, that works fine in a in a, say, a vertical apostolic network. It works fine in a corporation, but it doesn't work work very well if it's a movement. Yeah. So
so, again, movements are DNA based organizations. So, you know, they have some identity, some practices that are common. But, yeah, there's a lot of diversity in them. I remember, I should think about it, things you do that were a little bit stupid. So about ten, fifteen years ago, for some reason, I downloaded the Al Qaeda training manual because I'm interested in movements. Right? So movements... I mean, this is an interesting movement. Right? And I thought, uh-oh. I wonder if I'm being tracked. I'm amazed I'm actually in this country now because I I did download it, and I I only thought about it afterwards. But
It's starting to scare me now.
No. But it's interesting that Alcon is interesting. So, like, as a movement, I I disapprove of everything about it. I mean, it's a horrid organization evil. But but as a movement, it's worthy of kind of looking at... I mean, they can go down deep into culture. They can embed themselves locally. They, you know, they can recruit. They can multiply. You can't shoot an idea. You know, we had all the nations of the world going out after their mine country as well as yours. I spent trillions of dollars, never did wipe them out. You can think about that. There's something about the... That the the structure, the phenomenology of movement that really could be, you you know, can be learned. And hence, they have a training manual. Very minimal. It's three month boot campy kind of thing. Like whack a mole.
Whack a mole. Yeah. Keeps popping up. But
Yeah. You can't take them out because, you know, because it has this this very, very organic multiplication kind of value. Like, our coalitions have
two main things in common. One is the four r's, revival, restoration, reformation, reconciliation. The other one is being a spiritual, political, and economic influence in that city or nation. But the methodology of going going about that, you know, the systems that they put in place That's up to you. That's up to... Yeah. There you go. It's chaotic. Yeah. It's chaotic. It has to be. It has to be. Mhmm. Yeah. Because in order to re... To reach a nation, you have to reach it covertly before you ever see it overtly. And and the problem is with the pent up... Pentecostals and the charismatics especially, they advertise everything... Including the charismaniacs. Charismaniacs. They advertise before they do it. Right. You know, I was invited to a a group that... A secret group that had to do with a country that's a hard to access country, and and, I refused to go. I didn't wanna go to the meeting. Doctor Wagner wanted me to go. He said, this is right up your alley. Said, no. I'm not going. He said, why? I said, because the characters are invited. You know? And it'll be on their web pages and and their advertisement that they were at this meeting within... With anywhere from a week to three months. And guess what? It was. Because we have to declare. You know? And there's some things that we... That need to be hidden. Paul said, you know, he knew things that he wasn't about to share. You know? And so even even do... What is it? Deuteronomy twenty nine twenty nine, you know, the secret things belong to God with that which he reveals to us is for our children's children. So he... He's not revealing everything to us. Praise god. Any other questions or statements? Yes. Here. Here. You can grab my mic, son. Sure. You can go and pull out the bible here and Preach it. You know? Preach it, brother. Come on, brother.
I'll leave that to you guys. So do you see APES, right, either one of you, having the potential to be viewed in the recovered truth paradigm that you kinda spoke about? Right? Or is APES the function that you like talking about, like a tool that can be used as a ladder to take the church out of the religious secular trap that we're kind of in right now, which is like Christian... Christ Christ... Christianity... Christless Christianity. Right? And so if the first is the actual, you know, thing that we could face, as general Kelly said so. It wasn't the shepherds, you know, during the shepherd movement. Right? Shepherd movement? Yeah. But it was the followers. So then where do we move from there? You know? What were the steps? Is identity one of them? You know? Establishing that through discipleship, And the discipleship process is more important than any specific systematic approach. So I just... I know it's a little question. Sorry.
Yeah. Sure. About ten.
Yeah. You wanna go for it? I I think I think discipleship is preeminent. I I really I really feel like discipleship is really, really a a miss... Missing element in the church. And and which... And we have great teachers, but I think it's kinda like what the scripture says. We have we have 10,000 mentors, but only a few fathers. And the difference between mentors and fathers is teachers will educate you, but but fathers will impart... They'll import values and principles to you. They'll... They they will impart a way of life to you. And and I think when it comes to that, how do you know you even have a spiritual father? Because that has to be somebody that actually loves you and is committed to your success and to help you fulfill the vision that you have. That's what fathers do. You know, my two biggest mistakes in ministry, is when I acted like a general, when I should have acted like a father, and when I acted like a father, when I should have acted like a general. And because the the general cries out is there not a cause, and the father's crying out for children. And one has a vision for the war because the other one has a vision for the vision of of... For the calling of of of the son or daughter. And so they're they're very different. And I think the problem with discipleship, once again, it's always taught as a program. This is how you disciple people. But when you really disciple people, put your arm around them. You you go to you go to breakfast with them. You you take them with you. You you do things with them. And so so I think that's really a a missing element.
Going back to the other thing you said about it...... Just say on that... On... Is it Dallas Willard who probably, you know, is the premier kind of person on... He said nondiscipleship undermines everything else we seek to do. So if you don't disciple, everything else is undermined, and he's absolutely right, isn't he? He is right.
He is right. He's he's right here. So so, anyway, not not in this room. I mean, in Dallas. Yeah. So... But going back to APES going back to APES, I want you to see something. Imagine in your mind a wedge. And a wedge is is one of the one of the one of the most original military, meth... Methods, tactic. And the wedges, you you set up a wedge like that and you you go and you split their line at whatever point you can split it at, and then your line forms a circle, and that's called a killing field. And then you go in and you kill everything within the within the middle of that circle. And so APES to me is that. Not that we kill everything in the circle, instead we bring life to everything in the circle. But Not the wedge. It's the way it should be. But but a wedge but a wedge, you know, it says in first Corinthians 12, this this is interesting. First Corinthians 12, it says, first apostles, second prophets. And we wanna make it like like, it's... Well, that only means, like, first in line for lunch. Right. But but really really, it has... It does have to do with something governmental.... Front. First in the front line. First in the front line. The first one that gets chopped. You know? And so so so when you so when you form a wedge, let's say, there's the apostle, there's the prophet, there's the evangelist, there's the pastor, the teacher, they're all equally important in that wedge. And so you can't you cannot transform a church. You can't transform a a city or or a nation or a denomination, whatever you're talking about, without APES, you know, functioning in that kind of, first of all, functional coequality, but also understanding that there's an ordering God, there's an alignment in God that has to take place with APES going going through going through that. Yeah.
Well, I got a feeling we're gonna be tackled here, brother. He's he's come to take us down. Okay. Well, let me just try and answer that question with another diagram very quickly. Remember, I'd mentioned that I think that, you know, to deal with this APEST, the danger is right now because we focused on it so much today is to think that that itself is the answer to everything. Now it is the wedge. I think it is the Trojan horse for all the good things. But but in... If if we want a movement to happen, this is what I think. If we wanna head there, there are there are at least six elements that need to play. The Jesus, Lord piece, we have to clarify at a deep level, you know, our central kind of message. Discipleship, disciple making. We need to be clear about what is it to be a disciple and how we make them and and make sure we factor it into life of the community. Missionally incarnational. That is we need to go out, go deep, go out, go deep. It's how churches extend themselves over time and place. So you can see this dynamic happen. Apeist is one of them. You need it to both generate and sustain, but you can't Apeist on itself is not you need discipleship. The other ones are called organic systems. It has to do with chaotic stuff and all that. And how you organize and DNA and then, of course, liminality community, that's his adventure and risk. Why I say that is simply because I think we cannot simply say it's just apeist. But listen, if you enhance apeist, everything else is enhanced. If you enhance your discipleship, everything else is enhanced. And so we have to think like, you know, that is... And I think really movements are the way we're going to advance the cause of Christ in the twenty first century because the rest is on decline. There's no question about that. We have to turn turn that around.
Amen. This has been wonderful with Alan Hirsch. Good job. Thank you, brother. And I found I found a real lunchman here. I mean, we... And it's it's wonderful to to to discover you. It's been a great blessing. We've discovered you, gosh, about, what, a couple years ago. Right, Joe? And reading, you know... And I recommend all of you go out there right now, get out your Visa cards,
and get the books. And thank you so much for coming and serving like you have. And thank you very much for having me all. It's been fun to get to know you. Wow. It's like we, like, ran across the room together. Right?
Yeah. I believe in love at first. Love at first. Okay. Alright. God bless you. You have another session. Joseph, you're apostle. Yeah. Right.
Well, praise god. We...