Skip to content
Movemental Partner

Sermons & talks

Address

The King's Church on a Kingdom Mission - Alan Hirsch at Church Planting Canada Congress 2021

Alan Hirsch · Church Planting Canada Congress

Watch in the video library

Transcript

Transcript of the recording.

[Alan Hirsch] Hi. It's my honor, as always, to be invited to address the church planning congress at this time. I think I've been to two of the conferences physically over the last twelve years or so. I think it was when Cam Roxburgh was a leading. Cam, a dear colleague and friend. And I also love and deeply respect both Graham Singh. I know who led it for a while, and Jeff Christopherson. I do anything to work with those guys. I love them. And, well, being here, I guess, is part of why why they they invited me here, so I'm here. I'm gonna be doing a talk on movement dynamics here, and I'm gonna be a little informal. I'm gonna use a whiteboard. Hopefully, it doesn't detract from the core ideas I wanna share with you. I've been asked to talk about issues of movement dynamics, but with a particular focus on church planting. And I wanna bring in a focus on what I call a minimal ecclesiology, a kind of working adaptive form of it. I think this is a critical issue. I think it's critical for the Canadian context as this mine in Australia and certainly Europe and increasingly in The USA. It's critical because we have a long tradition of what might be called a maximal or heavyweight ecclesiology and not that very flexible kind of churches. And, obviously, in COVID, that's been shown to be quite quite fragile. And, also, it's not particularly best way to go about, I think, in a genuinely post Christian context. But if we're gonna have any chance of reversing the decline, we're simply gonna have to become a church that can rapidly multiply and is also inherently adaptive. In other words, we're gonna have to learn about being a movement again. And I I believe it's our deepest ethos. I'm on record with that, but I think this is a moment where we can actually recover the significance of it because we have to. In writing about paradigm issues, because we're gonna deal with paradigms, I always like what John Maynard Keynes, the economist, wrote in his book, the general theory of employment, interest, and money. Of course, it's on economic theory. But here's an interesting thing he wrote. He said the composition of this book, the book he was writing, has been for the author a long struggle of escape, and so must the reading of it be for most readers if the author's assault upon them is to be successful, a struggle of escape from habitual modes of thought and expression. The ideas which are here expressed so laboriously are extremely simple and should be obvious. Here, he ends this point. It says, the difficulty lies not with new ideas, but in escaping from the old ones, which ramify, which see their way into every corner of our minds. It's a brilliant comment, and it highlights how deeply entrenched certain habits of thinking, modes of thought are about the way we think about church, and they are deeply embedded in our mindset. And so it's a it's a a struggle for escaping these things, and I think we really have to grapple with it. We're moving... I wanna suggest, you know, we have to move first and foremost in in the level of paradigm. It's gonna start there at the level of imagination, at the level of vision. And so what I wanna share with you is on my lovely whiteboard is that... Is is is this idea of of how do we change paradigms and why it's important. If I said, for instance, folks, that... Here we are here, and I've got my my finger because my my pen isn't working. Hopefully, it makes sense still. And here we are, and we find ourselves in a moment in history where what has got us to this point of history is not gonna get us further. The prevailing modes of thinking, which I'm gonna kind of put as a kind of a kind of a a mindset, a kind of paradigm that rules our imagination. I'm gonna put it up there in our minds, and I'm gonna say that when we've come to this point where we realize, yeah, this is not the happiest of moments, we have been happier. Because as as I said, what has got us to this point in history is not exactly gonna get us further. We know that. Our best thinkers know this. It was designed for a different set of circumstances, completely different, and yet the prevailing thinking still dominates our minds. So it's said that Constantine is still the emperor of our imaginations, and we have to dethrone him if we're going to grow. Here we are, and I think this is what is happening in our day, and I think it's a it's a good thing. I personally believe it's a very good thing. We are kind of now in the point of history where we're beginning to grapple with a different way of thinking about the church, which is the way of what I call movement thinking. It's that movement swoosh kind of exponential growth curve. And here's what I think. It's... Is it a happy moment? Yes. But it's kind of like bemused, perplexed kind of happiness. Yes. We think it's right. It feels really good. It's intuitively correct. It's it's much closer to the ecclesiology you find in the scriptures themselves and in movements that change the world anyway. Methodism would be a good example. But, yeah, we're not that good at it. In fact, again, for those problems of habits of imagination, we really struggle to think into this so that we're getting better. We struggle also with churches, organizations which are formatted in the prevailing mode, the kind of the Christendom formatting of church. Now this is where it's really complex because it's deeply built into the muscle memory of the organizations that we lead. So even if we free our minds to some degree, you know, as we see over here, we free our minds. Nonetheless, it's a it's a challenge to to actually work with organizations that are deeply... That come... Born out of the previous modality. We wanna get it to movement. God wants to get us there. The gospel is about the advance of, you know, of the of the of the the story of Jesus in the world. The gates of hell do not prevail against us. God wants you to be a movement. I promise you. That's the intention of God, and you gotta get what you're doing moving. Here's the challenge for us. We have to work with the churches that we that we largely have to grapple with. Even if, like I said, you've won the battle of imagination, you've gotta, like, get, you know, the church out of your head into the church you actually worship in. It's gotta somehow make that dangerous journey into... To practice. And and that, I think, is the challenge. Here's the exciting thing about this, friends. And this is where I do believe God is is helping us even now. But I would suggest that the seed of this future, the possibility of movement is already present in the womb of the church right now. In other words, the seed of the future is already present in the womb of the church. The microcosm contains the macrocosm, and this is this notion of of latent potentials. They can be activated, and I believe God wants to kinda help us activate it. What we gotta do is loosen up here. This is where I'm gonna come address society of movement thinking, but also a minimal ecclesiology. Gonna loosen up the the the flexibility of that system that's got bible verses all over it, and it's gonna loosen up and and and and learn some tricks in becoming... I think it can be done, but it's gonna take a bit of effort on our behalf to make it work. And so we find that that that's... You know, we we... That's the challenge that we're gonna have to grapple with. Getting from paradigm to practice, getting the church out of our head into the world. So what I think ways forward on this is is to think about an ecclesiology that's more in the way of movements, movement dynamics. And, Hirsch, I think we're the one... Things that we have to grapple with, if I can, again, go back to my whiteboard, is that we have to grapple with the fact that movements really inevitably over time do tend to institutionalize and become the monument, the move from the movement, the monument kind of idea. And to become a movement again, there's a number of dynamics that we have to grapple with here. There's a different vibe that's going on this side of the equation than on that side of the equation. That should be obvious, but there's different patterns of behavior, different types of leadership. And I think this is where, of course, a... What I believe APEST will help because APEST is definitely at work on this side of the equation. No doubt about it. There's never been a movement, Jesus movement that went to scale without the fivefold typology of ministry of Ephesians four. It doesn't happen. It just doesn't. And what'll happen on the other side of equation is you lose some of that a post dynamic, and you end up with kind of pastors and teachers leading everything. And that's a certain way of thinking. They are important, but they're not generative, and that's the problem. It's it's formula for decline. But the atmosphere, what is important here about movement thinking is that you wanna cultivate the can do attitude that goes along with the the the the kind of up up curve, and and and and and that's kind of this can do that that Jesus intends to change the world, and he wants to use us. And we ourselves will, in some cases, be willing to die for that movement. And that's kind of something that can be cultivated and needs to be attended to. What it... What we often will have to grapple with is what the dynamic on this side of the equation, which is what we call the sociology of doubt or the institutionalization of doubt. That it's that it's a very different field on the other side, and we have to grapple with this stuff and if we're going to kinda be successful. And and then there's a whole lot of stuff again that we, you know, we we can think about in in in in in that regard. That's... But we gotta be able to move, and we can't just stay where we are. And so I wanna suggest some kind of exercises, perhaps, or ways forward for us that we... First of all, foremost, we should begin with the end in mind. In other words, if you wanna be a movement, you need to begin with the kind of an idea of movement. So... You know? But here's the deal. You wanna begin with the end in mind. Be clear about that. Get your thinking clear about what a movement is and get into it. But make sure you stay there. You gotta end with the beginning in mind. Often what we see that people who might start out in a more movemental way end up in the more institutional way because they haven't stuck with the the the the mental model that is required for that. And so I think it's very important to keep consistency of organizational DNA throughout the whole life cycle of the organization. And that's the way you might keep the regenerative aspects of movements going. Stay on the idea of movement. Be clear about it and get on to it. Secondly, just maybe maybe I wouldn't say secondly, but the way of doing this is two ideas that I wanna suggest you. Don't plan churches. Say that to the church planting congress. Don't plan churches, friends. Plant movements. Begin with the end of mind. Now by the way... Just by the way, it's interesting that Jesus never commands us to plant churches. In fact, I'm not aware in scripture that we're told to plant churches. And then you mean wrong here. Don't hear what I'm not saying. I do believe in church planting, but the problem is whenever we use the word church, don't if it always doesn't go to that former church. It always ends up with a very set ecclesiology that just looks like the European format that we've been doing for so long. And that's really the problem. So plant movements instead. Rethink that whole thing. Begin with the end in mind. Secondly, don't plant churches. Plant the gospel. Just, you know... And the gospel as the seed of the church. In other words, that... Know, if you think about it in biblical language, it is that you plant the gospel and Jesus builds the church. We don't get to build the church. Jesus builds it. But when you plant the gospel, it's something more prior to it. It's more primitive, more fundamental to churches. The gospel creates the church and the church community. The good news creates us in that sense. And and and when you do plan gospel, you you you allow the church to emerge differently in different settings because you're not set on a certain format of how the church should express itself. Let's begin with the end in mind and various little exercises you can do to think about that. The the next one I'd like to share with you is the idea of spreading like a virus, to spread like a virus. Now it's interesting. This is a dangerous metaphor for our time given the pandemic. And if I may, I'm going to misuse scripture a little bit and say from Proverbs where it says, I'm gonna say, go to the virus, you sluggard, and learn from its ways. I I think there's so much to learn from viruses. They are antifragile, and they can spread like crazy. That little thing, you can't even see it, and it's changing the world. And it can reproduce rapidly, and it can, you know, change its kind of variation quite quickly as well. It's very, very powerful as a metaphor for movement. And, interestingly, in epidemiology, they talk about the infected person as a vector. I like that language, a vector. The idea that that, you know, that every person who's infected, they can infect others. They become an infected agent in the system. And I think, again, if you think about disciples or churches as vectors, I think it's a very useful metaphor. One of my favorite movies, it goes back a number of years now, but some of you would remember it. And for those who are not aware of it, I encourage you to take a look at it. It's a great movie. Anyway, it's called pay it forward. Pay it forward starts with a kid in school, and the teacher who just wanted them to do a mental exercise, but he didn't intend in any more than this. He he suggests to this group of 12 year olds to come up with something that would change the world. Long story short, this one kid in the class comes up with this notion of pay it forward. Now pay it forward is if you were to do a good deed for someone. So in other words, like... So here he is, kid, pay it forward to someone. You know, the tendency to want to pay it back is always the strong thing. And he says, no. No. No. No. No. No. Don't pay it back. Don't pay me back. But here's the deal. So I'm doing a good deed for you. You pay it forward to three other people, and you do the same thing to them. Don't pay me back. Pay it forward. So so let's see how this plays out. If you, you know, one on one one goes to three. Don't pay me back. Pay it forward. Three goes to whatever it is, nine in this case. And you're gonna get the idea very quickly, and I'm not gonna be able to do much more. But here's what... How it plays out, and it begins to spread like wildfire. And there you see that movement swoosh begin to happen there. Paid forward movement. Now interestingly there, friends, is is this... In paid forward movement, I mean, like, here is the the kind of secret to changing the world. Now over here, it is... Like, it doesn't look like much in the beginning. Right? One three nine dot eight. It's pretty small. But here's the thing. It's about in 16, 17 iterations, you've reached the population of North America. And in probably about another 10 after that, you've pretty much reached the population of the world. You can literally, following this methodology, change the world with a pay it forward virus like growth movement. And and and and let's play this out. Imagine that we do this for church planting. Every church that exists commits itself to to church planting, planting two other churches, two, three in its lifetime. So if a church lasts six six month years, you you you literally get them to pay it forward. Plant three others, and you say, hey. You don't have to tithe or they don't give us back. Just. But you commit them to doing the same thing. Put your hand on the bible. Actually, you're very close to the scriptures on this. You can say, put your hand there and commit yourself to paying it forward to the the movement that Jesus started. And and, listen, you know, if if you if you did this with discipleship, not alone church planning. What about discipleship? Everyone... That's all we have to do. We don't do anything else with Jesus other than bring three other people, win them to faith, and disciple them, and commit them to do the same thing, to win three other people in faith and disciple them. Folks, if we just stay on that, we change the world. And that's remarkable, and we should think about this because it's something that really does predict us. It's... This is movement thinking. The the scalability, the capacity to go to scale is in the setup of the organization. This is what I call fractal organizing. Now fractal... Fractals are patterns that recur at scale. It's a way of looking into infinity because the same pattern begins to emerge at at every scale of an organization. So to the degree that we're able to do this and to build scalability into every aspect of the organization, you begin to kind of create an organization that can really can really grow like a movement. I remember, you know, someone saying, like, I believe this idea that every believer every believer, every dedicated disciple is a victor, you know, in a virus of the gospel. I remember saying something like this to someone, oh gosh, somewhere in America. And this guy was leading a very large church, and he said, well, I I... And I'm not sure if I understand you, Alan. I... He said, are you saying to me that every believer is a site? Now that was his language. It was a multisite church. You're saying that every believer is a possible site. And I said, yep. I wouldn't use that language. But, yes, it's exactly what I'm saying. Every believer is a site. Everyone is able to do this kind of thing. And if you can get there, you get to change the world in a significant way. Another suggestion, and, again, this goes to the issue of minimal ecclesiology, is that we have to produce movements or organizations that are lightweight and reproducible. I think it goes without saying that institutionalism is a huge problem, a huge problem. One, because when you've got a huge institution that's been there a long time, it has what we call a towering effect. It stuns the members into passivity. Oh, I'm never gonna change that. This is overwhelming. I'm never gonna do that. And these institutions have this capacity to make us cower in a in a little way. And I think this is a problem. I don't know who said this. I think it was Picasso. I can't source it exactly, but it's kind of a good statement. For those who really are on about preserving tradition, can I suggest this? And I think we should be, by the way. Tradition is important. Traditionalism is a problem, but tradition is important. But the best way to preserve tradition is not to wear your granddad's old hat, but to have children. If you really understand it, if, you know, if you really wanna pass your DNA on and if you wanna pass your legacy, your your name or your legacy on to the future, well, the best way to do that, friends, is to have children. And if you do it well, you raise them really well. You don't control them and make them like you, where granddad's old head seem worse. They're gonna be the own people. They're gonna be different and at the same time similar to you. I think that's that's good advice. Can I encourage you in the more, you know, mainline churches to please consider that? Have you some children, and I think you'll find that that's the way you you pass pass on your future. And and here's the the challenge again on on doing this is to develop a... An ecclesiology that can suit the kids. Develop a minimal ecclesiology. And this is a huge church for heritage heritage churches, by the way. The heritage church is is this huge kind of tradition to pass on. The problem is, friends, that they're not readily reproducible. So, you know, if in a big, you know, heritage church, mainline denomination, it takes you seven years of study, two degrees to be a minister of Jesus Christ, the very thing you were given in your baptism. Seven years to to drive the liturgy. Praise be to god. But, you know, if if that's true for your organization, you're not going anywhere fast, and it self selects because certain people will not go that journey with you, and the... Some of those people are the ones you need. But here's the thing is if you you... You're into, you know, megachurches and not into that kind of denominational stuff or... Well, if it takes you, you know, x million dollar budget and a professional band and a Sunday worship of 200 people plus before you'll even call yourself a church, well, that's not reproducible either, friends. It's not reproducible. And here's the thing is that if we are able to think about reproducibility as, like, something that the... I don't say average, but the committed average disciple, not average in the bad sense, but your... But a committed believer of Jesus Christ can... Should be able to do it. If you can get your ecclesiology to that point where it's readily reproducible by the committed devoted disciple of Jesus, you are into the game again. And this reproducibly, it implies reproducibility, an ability to reproduce. One of the best metaphors in in in in forgotten ways, I use Al Qaeda as an example. It's unfortunate, but it's true, but unfortunate nonetheless in that... You know, it's just not the best example. So the better example I have is is in the starfish kinda and the spider imagery. And by the way, Rob Wegner, Lance Ford, and myself have just produced a book about a few months now on topic, on all this minimal ecclesiology and reproducibility based on the starfish dynamics called the starfish and the spirit, and I encourage you to take a look at it. But the the metaphor is great, so let me just give it to you, Yeah. If you don't already know it. If this say, this is not great art, forgive me. This is your spider. And the spider has eight legs and, you know, all that other stuff. Now a spider's a very, it's a brilliant... Like Spider Man. It's a brilliant brilliant organization. You know? And it can be exceedingly effective, you know, as a as a animal insect that, you know, can jump incredible places and very strong got, you know, weave the webs and all that stuff. Now what if, friends... And I think of this as a metaphor for organization. Right? And the the legs are your departments or, you know, parts of the body is the department. Let's take one of the legs off. Do you think the spine is gonna manage at that point? Well, I don't know. Yeah. Probably. I I would say so. Take another leg off. Yeah. Maybe. I mean, you gotta kill, you know, flies and lights, and maybe maybe take another leg off. I don't think so. I don't mean in in in organizational theory, if you got three dysfunctional departments, you're probably you're probably not gonna be around long. Let's put them back. Now if, let's say, in the spider organization, you took out the head, now what's gonna happen is that the whole organization dies. The whole spider dies. Why? Because power and function are concentrated in a few at the top, and in this case, the head of the organization. If you take out the head, you take the whole organization down. It's very vulnerable at the head. And, actually, if you can't really see this, that this is direct implications for for New Testament ecclesiology. So that's a spider organization. Tricky. And yet most of our organizations follow this line. Let's go now to the starfish. Now the starfish, again, I'm not the greatest artist, but I think that'll do. So starfish. Now starfish is... It it kinda looks similar to playing with me. It's got legs and all that stuff. Now here's the thing about starfish. What happens if you cut a leg off a starfish? Well, it will grow into another starfish, actually. What if you cut the thing into 10 pieces, or more? How many starfish you got? Well, you got 10 or more starfish. Because here's the thing about the starfish. Every part of the system has got the hole in it that can reproduce the the hole, and it's what we call holographic organization. I won't go there, but if you were interested, that's where you wanna look. Each part can reproduce the hole. And and this is not the only organize... Organism in in in in nature that does this. There's a thing called the immortal jellyfish. Immortal jellyfish, when it's under threat, it dissolves itself entirely into protoplasm, falls to the bottom on the ocean, and the protoplasm just produces thousands of new jellyfish when it's under threat. Interesting, Matt. Great metaphor again for our age. Chew on it. So here's the thing. If this is not already clear, in movements that change the world, you wanna get as many people as possible into the game, everyone in the game, activating the agency of all of god's people. And let me say this. This includes men and women. I can... I prophesy to you. If you do not get the women more engaged, you will never, I prophesy this, you will never be a movement. You cannot do it with half the body of Christ because god... Jesus has given you all that, and the agency of all of god's people has to be brought to bear. Movements that change the world engage everyone in the game. And for the most part, we have... In history, Protestants have, in a large part, believed in priesthood of all believers as a doctrine, but very, very seldom do we believe in it as a practice. And when... As soon as we do, we kinda smother it down, and that's the problem of clericalism. It's a movement killer, friends, because you can... Until you can activate everyone in as many as possible, you you you just can't get to movement dynamics. Minimal ecclesiology, remember, is important. Let me give you... Leave you with one image, and I'm finished at this point. Can I suggest you that if if you can agree with me that every seed is the potential for a tree? I think you'll agree. And every tree has a potential for a forest. But here's the thing. It's all contained in the smallest part. The the seed has a potential for a forest in it. And a spark has a potential for a flame, and a flame is a potential for a forest fiber. It's all contained in every spark. Now not every seed becomes a forest. Not every spark, thank you, becomes a flame, but it can. And here is the thing is that I think that you can see the metaphor here. If we were able, for instance, to look at the people that we lead in the in the various churches and organizations that we lead, if we could see them as seeds containing a potential future that god wants to birth through them, you're onto it. If you can organize it, you'll be a movement. So there you have it. I suggest these to you humbly to think about, in this church planning congress, as you negotiate the complexities of the post pandemic church. There is no way back. The way forward is, I believe, in the direction I'm pointing you. Test it. Know it if it is true. I I pray that God will bug you with it. In Jesus' name. Amen.